Why refinance timing and payoff-date assumptions must match
A mismatch between the maturity date on your current loan and the date you assume you will close a new permanent loan creates a refinance gap that lenders and examiners treat as credit risk. This guide provides a concrete evidence checklist to identify, document and address that gap before you submit a financing request.
A mismatch between the maturity date on your current loan and the date you assume you will close a new permanent loan creates a refinance gap that lenders and examiners treat as credit risk. This guide provides a concrete evidence checklist to identify, document and address that gap before you submit a financing request.
Identify your current loan maturity and payoff date assumptions
Record the exact maturity date from your current loan agreement. Then write down the date you have assumed you will close and fund a new permanent loan. If those two dates are not closely aligned, you have a refinance timing gap. The gap matters because banks evaluate whether a borrower can replace existing debt at a future date under reasonable terms and prevailing market conditions . A gap in your file suggests you have not yet aligned your refinance plan with the actual maturity.
Suggested way to prepare: create a simple two-column table. In the left column, list each current loan with its maturity date. In the right column, list the assumed close date for the replacement financing. If any right-column date is later than the left-column date, flag that loan for further work.
Compare the rent roll snapshot to the trailing twelve months
A current rent roll is a snapshot of who is in the building today and what they pay. A trailing twelve-month operating statement (T-12) is a historical record of income and expenses over the past year, reported on either a cash or accrual basis. These two documents cover different time periods and may show different totals. Before comparing them, note the timing difference. The T-12 may include months when occupancy was lower or when rent concessions were granted. The rent roll reflects only current occupancy and rents.
Your task: pull the most recent rent roll and the most recent T-12. For each, calculate gross rent, collected income, net operating income, capital expenditures, debt service and equity cash flow. Then identify any variance between the two. A large variance may indicate that the property’s current performance is not yet stable enough to underwrite a permanent loan [1].
Document the property's stabilization timeline
Permanent lenders underwrite in-place cash flow adjusted for vacancy, expenses, and reserves [1]. If the property is still leasing up, recovering from renovation, or experiencing tenant turnover, the in-place cash flow may not yet meet the lender's underwriting tests. The refinance risk increases when the property’s financial performance is declining or when market conditions have changed .
Suggested way to prepare: record the date the property reached its current occupancy level. Note any planned or ongoing capital improvements and their expected completion dates. If the property is not yet stabilized, identify the bridge loan or other interim financing that will cover the gap until it is.
Prepare a refinance stress test worksheet
Transaction-level stress testing can provide insight into a borrower’s ability to meet refinancing requirements if the borrower’s financial condition declines or market conditions deteriorate, such as interest rates increase, market terms tighten, expenses increase or collateral values fall . You are not required to run a bank-grade stress test, but you can prepare a simple worksheet that shows how the property’s debt service coverage would change under a higher interest rate, a lower occupancy or a higher expense assumption.
Suggested way to prepare: create a worksheet with three columns. In the first column, list your base-case net operating income and debt service. In the second column, apply an increase in the assumed refinance interest rate and recalculate debt service. In the third column, reduce net operating income by a reasonable amount and recalculate coverage. If any scenario produces a debt service coverage ratio below the lender's actual minimum requirement, ask the actual lender what that minimum is.
Compare your leverage to current lender standards
Permanent lenders typically size a loan using several tests simultaneously, including loan-to-value, debt service coverage ratio, and debt yield as defined by the lender's underwriting. The most restrictive test generally determines the maximum loan amount. If you assume a loan amount that exceeds what current lender underwriting standards would support, you have a refinance gap.
Your task: obtain current loan-to-value and debt service coverage requirements from at least one active permanent lender in your market. Do not rely on a single source or on terms from a loan that closed two years ago. Compare those requirements to your current leverage and projected debt service. If the lender’s maximum loan amount is lower than the balance you need to repay, identify the source of the shortfall.
Identify prepayment terms on the current loan
Prepayment terms often deserve as much attention as the rate, particularly when a sale or refinancing before maturity is possible [1]. Yield maintenance, defeasance, and step-down prepayment premiums can make an early exit expensive. If your current loan has a prepayment penalty that would reduce the refinance proceeds, you need to account for that cost in your sources-and-uses table.
Suggested way to prepare: locate the prepayment section of your current loan agreement. Record the prepayment premium formula, any minimum premium and the dates when the premium steps down. Calculate the cost of prepaying on your assumed refinance close date. Add that cost to the total debt you need to retire.
Ask the actual lender about assumption and extension options
Whether a buyer can assume a commercial permanent loan depends on the loan documents and the lender [1]. The same is true for extension options. If you plan to sell the property or extend the current loan rather than refinance, you need to know whether those options are available and under what conditions.
Suggested way to prepare: write a short list of questions for the current lender: (1) Can the loan be assumed by a qualified buyer? (2) What are the assumption fees and conditions? (3) Are there any extension options, and what are the extension terms? (4) What is the process and timeline to request an extension? Record the answers in your file.
Frequently asked questions
What is a refinance timing gap? A refinance timing gap occurs when the maturity date of your current loan is earlier than the date you assume you will close a new permanent loan. The gap creates a period during which you have no committed financing in place, which increases credit risk from the lender’s perspective.
How do I know if my property is ready for a permanent loan? A property is generally ready when it is complete, has reached stable occupancy and produces income that meets the lender’s tests, typically debt service coverage and often debt yield [1]. If your trailing twelve-month operating statement shows significant variance from the current rent roll, or if the property is still leasing up, it may not yet be ready.
What should I do if my current loan has a prepayment penalty? Calculate the prepayment cost as of your assumed refinance close date. Add that cost to the total debt you need to retire. If the cost is material, ask the actual lender whether the penalty can be waived or reduced, and discuss with your tax advisor whether the cost is deductible.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a refinance model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).