Documenting refinance costs that remain unknown before a lender quote
This guide provides a concrete evidence checklist and worksheet to help a sponsor prepare for a refinance gap analysis, distinguishing known costs from assumptions and explaining how each item affects the financing discussion with lenders.
This guide provides a concrete evidence checklist and worksheet to help a sponsor prepare for a refinance gap analysis, distinguishing known costs from assumptions and explaining how each item affects the financing discussion with lenders.
Refinance risk and your file gaps
Refinance risk is the chance that a borrower cannot refinance under current market conditions . Banks assess this risk at underwriting, during monitoring, and near maturity . For you, the sponsor, the practical task is to document every cost that will appear in a lender's underwriting—even those you have not yet locked in. A lender's analysis includes determining whether you can meet current underwriting standards, including prevailing interest rates, for similar loans . The stronger your underlying financial performance, the more refinance options are available . This guide helps you prepare a refinance gap analysis worksheet that shows lenders you understand your own numbers.
What a permanent lender underwrites
A commercial permanent loan is typically long-term senior financing for a stabilized, income-producing property [1]. Permanent lenders underwrite the property's in-place cash flow, adjusted for items such as vacancy, expenses and reserves [1]. They size a loan with several tests: maximum loan-to-value, minimum debt service coverage ratio (underwritten net operating income divided by annual debt service), and often a minimum debt yield (underwritten net operating income divided by the loan amount) [1]. The most restrictive test generally sets the maximum loan amount [1]. Lenders also look at the rent roll, lease terms, tenant quality, and the sponsor's net worth, liquidity and record [1].
Your refinance gap analysis worksheet
Prepare a single workpaper that lists every cost line item for the refinance, with three columns: known amount, estimated amount, and source of the estimate. Use the headings below as sections. This is not a mandatory lender form; it is a suggested way to organize information so you can identify gaps before a lender asks.
Known loan costs
Record the current loan balance, maturity date, prepayment penalty formula (if any), and any lockout period. If the loan is interest-only, note the remaining interest-only period. The OCC notes that refinance risk primarily affects loans with principal balances remaining at maturity and borrowers who rely on recurring debt . For a permanent loan, any balance left at maturity is commonly repaid with a refinancing or a sale [1]. Identify whether your current loan has a balloon payment or is fully amortizing.
Estimated third-party report costs
Permanent lenders require third-party reports: appraisal, property condition assessment, and environmental site assessment [1]. For each, record the estimated cost, the vendor (if you have a quote), and the expected timeline. If you have not yet ordered these, note that the cost is unknown and explain why (for example, waiting for lender selection). Ask your actual lender what phase of environmental assessment they require.
Estimated legal and closing costs
Legal fees vary by transaction complexity. Record the estimated cost for borrower's counsel, recording fees, and any transfer taxes. Ask your actual lender for their typical legal fee range. If you are using a loan assumption provision, note whether the lender charges an assumption fee [1].
Interest rate and swap assumptions
Permanent loans can be fixed or floating rate [1]. If you plan to use an interest rate swap or cap, record the estimated cost and the source of that estimate (e.g., a broker quote). The OCC guidance notes that banks may detail the prudent use of interest rate swaps and caps . If you have not yet priced a swap, note that the cost will depend on the term and rate environment at closing.
Prepayment terms and exit strategy
Prepayment terms often deserve as much attention as the rate, particularly when a sale or refinancing before maturity is possible [1]. Yield maintenance and defeasance can make an early exit expensive [1]. Record the prepayment structure you are targeting (e.g., step-down premium, yield maintenance, defeasance) and note whether you expect to hold the property through the full loan term. If a sale during the loan term is likely, whether a buyer can assume the loan matters as well [1]. Identify whether the loan documents allow assumption and under what conditions.
Reconciling your rent roll and operating statement
A current rent roll is a snapshot of in-place leases as of today. A trailing twelve (T-12) is a historical report of income and expenses over the past twelve months. Before comparing totals, explain the timing difference: the rent roll shows current contracted rent, while The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis. Distinguish gross rent, collected income, net operating income (NOI), capital expenditures (capex), debt service, and equity cash flow. The lender will underwrite to in-place net operating income and occupancy [1].
Identifying borrower-specific risk factors
Borrower-specific drivers for heightened refinance risk include high leverage, constrained liquidity, a significant volume of near-term maturities, poor financial performance, or unpopular market sentiment . Record your own leverage ratio, liquidity reserves, and any near-term maturities on other loans. If you have multiple properties, list each loan's maturity date and balance. The OCC guidance states that banks should have processes to identify, measure, monitor, and control refinance risk at both the transaction and portfolio levels . Your workpaper helps the lender see that you have done this self-assessment.
Preparing for the lender's stress test
One common method to assess refinance risk is multivariable stress testing . While you cannot run the lender's internal model, you can prepare by asking your actual lender what interest rate scenarios they use. Record the current interest rate environment and note that refinance risk increases in rising interest rate environments . If you have a fixed-rate loan, note that a swap breakage cost may apply if the loan is repaid early [1].
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a rent roll and a T-12?
A rent roll is a snapshot of current in-place leases, showing contracted rent and occupancy as of today. A T-12 is a historical report of income and expenses over the past twelve months. The timing difference matters: the rent roll shows what is expected, while The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis. Lenders use both to underwrite in-place net operating income.
How do I estimate costs for third-party reports if I have not chosen a lender?
Record the cost as unknown and explain why. You can ask a few vendors for a rough quote based on property type, size, and location, but note that the final cost depends on the lender's specific requirements. Ask your actual lender what phase of environmental assessment they require.
Does a loan assumption affect my refinance costs?
Yes, if you plan to sell the property before maturity, whether a buyer can assume the loan depends on the loan documents and the lender [1]. CMBS loans and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac multifamily loans typically allow assumption by a qualified buyer with approval and a fee [1]. Record the assumption terms in your workpaper as a potential future cost.
Next step
Share your completed refinance gap analysis worksheet with the sponsor team. Include the property, business plan, amount, and timing. Submission is a preliminary request, not an engagement or lender submission.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a refinance model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).