Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Documenting prepayment costs in a refinance sources-and-uses schedule

A concrete worksheet for sponsors preparing a refinance to document and present prepayment costs, distinguishing between yield maintenance, defeasance, and step-down premiums, and explaining how these costs affect the lender's underwriting of the refinance.

Source: CodexTopic: Refinance gap analysis1253 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A concrete worksheet for sponsors preparing a refinance to document and present prepayment costs, distinguishing between yield maintenance, defeasance, and step-down premiums, and explaining how these costs affect the lender's underwriting of the refinance.

When a sponsor refinances an existing commercial permanent loan before its scheduled maturity, the existing lender typically charges a prepayment premium. This cost can be significant and must be included in the sources-and-uses schedule of the new loan request. Omitting or underestimating this cost can create a shortfall between the debt proceeds and the cash needed to close, potentially delaying or jeopardizing the refinance.

This guide explains how to document prepayment costs, how this information influences the financing discussion, and how to distinguish between source facts and assumptions. It includes a practical worksheet you can prepare for your refinance request.

Understanding prepayment cost types

Commercial permanent loans vary in their prepayment terms [1]. Three common structures are yield maintenance, defeasance, and step-down premiums. Each involves a different cost calculation and requires specific documentation.

Yield maintenance requires the borrower to pay a premium designed to compensate the lender for the difference between the loan's interest rate and a reinvestment rate, typically a Treasury yield, over the remaining term. This cost depends on the spread between the note rate and current Treasury rates, as well as the remaining term [1].

Defeasance involves substituting the property collateral with government or qualifying securities whose payments cover the remaining scheduled loan payments, rather than repaying the loan early. The cost includes purchasing a portfolio of Treasuries or agency securities, plus legal and servicing fees [1].

Step-down premiums decrease over the loan term according to a schedule specified in the loan documents. The cost is predetermined and does not depend on interest rates [1].

To prepare this information, identify which prepayment structure applies to your existing loan by reviewing the loan agreement or note. For CMBS loans, prepayment terms are typically specified in the pooling and servicing agreement. For loans from banks or life insurance companies, check the loan documents for prepayment provisions.

How prepayment costs affect the refinance discussion

The prepayment cost is a use of funds at the refinance closing. It must be paid from the new loan proceeds, the sponsor's equity, or another source. If the new loan amount is based on the property's value or income, the prepayment cost effectively reduces the net proceeds available to the sponsor.

Refinance risk is the risk that borrowers will not be able to replace existing debt at a future date under reasonable terms and prevailing market conditions . A large prepayment cost can increase this risk by consuming cash that might otherwise serve as a liquidity buffer or by requiring additional equity contribution.

Effective analysis of refinance risk includes determining whether a borrower can meet current underwriting standards, including interest rates, for similar loans . The prepayment cost is part of the total cost of the refinance and should be factored into the borrower's ability to qualify for the new loan.

Preparing the prepayment cost worksheet

Below is a practical worksheet you can prepare. Record the information for your existing loan and the proposed refinance. This is a suggested way to organize information, not a mandatory lender process.

Prepayment cost worksheet

  1. Existing loan information - Lender name - Loan number - Original loan amount - Current outstanding principal balance - Note rate - Origination date - Maturity date - Prepayment structure (yield maintenance / defeasance / step-down / other) - Prepayment lockout period end date (if applicable) - Prepayment premium calculation formula or schedule - Contact for prepayment quote (lender name and phone)

  2. Prepayment cost estimate - Date of estimate - Estimated prepayment premium amount - Estimated defeasance cost (if applicable) - Estimated legal and administrative fees - Total estimated prepayment cost - Source of estimate (lender quote / loan document calculation / third-party estimate) - Expiration date of estimate (if any)

  3. Refinance sources and uses - New loan amount (proposed) - Sponsor equity contribution (proposed) - Other sources - Payoff of existing loan principal - Prepayment cost - Closing costs (appraisal, legal, title, etc.) - Reserves - Net proceeds to sponsor

Requesting a prepayment quote from the existing lender

Request a written prepayment quote from the existing lender. The quote should specify the prepayment premium amount, the calculation method, the effective date, and the expiration date. For yield maintenance loans, ask for the Treasury yield used in the calculation. For defeasance, request a list of approved securities and an estimate of the portfolio cost.

Record the date you requested the quote and the date you received it. Since prepayment quotes can expire, update the estimate if the refinance closing is delayed.

Reconciling the prepayment cost with the sources-and-uses schedule

Compare the total prepayment cost with the sources available at closing. Sources include the new loan proceeds plus any sponsor equity or other funds. Uses include the existing loan payoff, the prepayment cost, closing costs, and any reserves.

Identify any gap between sources and uses. If the new loan amount is insufficient to cover all uses, the sponsor must contribute additional equity or the loan amount must increase. This gap analysis is a suggested way to prepare information for lender discussions.

Distinguishing source facts from assumptions

The prepayment cost estimate from the existing lender is a source fact. The new loan amount proposed in the refinance request is an assumption until a lender issues a term sheet. The sponsor's equity contribution is an assumption until funded. Closing costs are estimates until third-party quotes are obtained.

Label each item in the worksheet as "source fact" or "assumption." Update the worksheet as facts replace assumptions. This practice helps avoid presenting a preliminary request as a finalized financing plan.

How prepayment terms affect lender selection for the new loan

Prepayment terms on the new loan deserve attention alongside the interest rate, especially when a sale or refinancing before maturity is possible [1]. Yield maintenance and defeasance can make an early exit costly, while a step-down prepayment premium declines over the term [1]. If a sale during the loan term is likely, whether a buyer can assume the loan is also important [1].

When selecting a lender for the new permanent loan, compare prepayment structures side by side. A loan with a lower rate but expensive yield maintenance may cost more overall if the property is sold or refinanced early. Conversely, a loan with a slightly higher rate but a shorter lockout period and a step-down premium may offer more flexibility.

FAQs

How do I get a prepayment quote from my existing lender?

Contact the lender's loan servicing department or relationship manager. Request a written quote stating the prepayment premium amount, calculation method, effective date, and expiration date. For yield maintenance loans, ask for the Treasury yield used. For defeasance, request the portfolio cost estimate and a list of approved securities.

What if my existing loan has a prepayment lockout period?

If the lockout period has not expired, prepayment may not be allowed or may trigger a substantial penalty. Review the loan documents for the lockout end date. If the lockout is still in effect, the refinance may need to wait until it expires, or the sponsor may need to negotiate a waiver with the existing lender.

Does the prepayment cost affect the new lender's underwriting?

The new lender typically underwrites the property's income and the borrower's creditworthiness, not the prepayment cost on the existing loan. However, the prepayment cost affects the sources-and-uses schedule and the sponsor's net proceeds. If the prepayment cost creates a funding gap that the sponsor cannot fill with equity, the new lender may require a larger equity contribution or a lower loan amount.

Model this deal and request financing

Run a refinance model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.

Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.

Open the refinance model

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. Wraith permanent loans