Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Testing a refinance with lower NOI and unchanged property value

A step-by-step guide for a commercial real estate sponsor to prepare an evidence checklist that compares a property's current net operating income with the income assumed at origination, stress-test debt service coverage, and identify gaps that affect refinance discussions.

Source: CodexTopic: Refinance gap analysis874 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A step-by-step guide for a commercial real estate sponsor to prepare an evidence checklist that compares a property's current net operating income with the income assumed at origination, stress-test debt service coverage, and identify gaps that affect refinance discussions.

When a property's net operating income (NOI) has declined but the appraised value has not changed, a sponsor needs to test whether the lower income still supports the requested refinance amount. This guide walks through a concrete workpaper—the Refinance Stress-Test Worksheet—and explains how each piece of information affects the financing discussion.

Calculate underwritten net operating income from the current figures

Start with gross potential rent from the rent roll. Subtract a vacancy and collection loss that reflects the property's actual experience over the T-12 period, not the market average. Deduct operating expenses—management fees, utilities, repairs, insurance, property taxes—again using the T-12 as the base. The result is the current underwritten NOI. Compare this to the NOI that was used at the time the original loan was originated. If the current NOI is lower, quantify the dollar decline. [1] Lenders size a permanent loan using multiple tests, including a minimum debt service coverage ratio (underwritten NOI divided by annual debt service). A lower NOI reduces the maximum loan amount under that test, even if the property value remains unchanged.

Distinguish gross rent, collected income, NOI, capital expenditures, debt service, and equity cash flow

A common confusion in refinance discussions is mixing these terms. Gross rent is the total contractual rent before any vacancy or expense. Collected income is what actually hit the bank account after vacancies, concessions, and bad debt. NOI is collected income minus operating expenses but before debt service and capital expenditures. Capital expenditures (roof replacement, HVAC, parking lot resurfacing) are not operating expenses; they are deducted after NOI to arrive at cash flow before debt service. Debt service is the annual principal and interest payment. Equity cash flow is what remains after all expenses, capex, and debt service. When you present your worksheet, label each line clearly. [1] Permanent lenders underwrite NOI, not gross rent or collected income alone, and they adjust for items such as vacancy, expenses, and reserves.

Prepare a Refinance Stress-Test Worksheet

Create a one-page workpaper with the following sections: - Current rent roll: date, occupancy %, gross potential rent - T-12 summary: gross collections, total operating expenses, actual NOI - Current underwritten NOI (after vacancy and expense adjustments) - Original loan NOI (from the origination underwriting) - Dollar decline in NOI - Existing annual debt service - Current debt service coverage (current NOI / existing debt service) - Stressed debt service coverage (current NOI / (existing debt service * stressed payment factor) to simulate a payment increase consistent with a 100-200 basis point rate increase) - Current debt yield (current NOI / requested loan amount) - Current LTV (requested loan amount / appraised value) - Gap identified: which test is the most restrictive?

This worksheet is a suggested way to organize information. It is not a mandatory lender form. Share it with your actual lender or debt arranger to focus the discussion on the specific gap.

Ask the actual lender about its underwriting assumptions

Every lender applies its own vacancy, expense, and reserve assumptions. [1] Permanent lenders differ: banks, life insurance companies, CMBS lenders, and agency programs each have distinct underwriting criteria. Do not assume that the lender will use your T-12 vacancy rate or your expense ratio. Ask the lender: What vacancy assumption do you apply to this property type? Do you use actual expenses or market standards? What is your minimum debt service coverage and debt yield? Record the answers and compare them to your worksheet. The OCC guidance states that a prudent assessment of refinance risk includes the performance of the underlying project or asset, the timing of refinancing, current market liquidity, and the cost of refinancing. Knowing the lender's assumptions lets you test whether your gap is real or can be closed by a different underwriting approach.

How do I know if my NOI decline is temporary or permanent?

Review the T-12 month by month. If the decline is concentrated in a few months due to a one-time event (a major tenant move-out, a seasonal dip, a natural disaster), you may be able to show the lender that the property has since stabilized. If the decline is sustained over six to twelve months, the lender is likely to treat it as the new baseline. The OCC notes that declining industry fundamentals or changes in commodity prices can increase refinance risk.

Can an unchanged appraised value compensate for lower NOI?

No. Lenders apply multiple tests independently. A high LTV may pass, but if debt service coverage or debt yield fails, the loan amount is capped by the most restrictive test. [1] The lender sizes the loan with all tests at once, and the most restrictive sets the maximum. You need to satisfy each test, not just one.

Should I include capital expenditures in my NOI calculation?

No. NOI excludes capital expenditures. However, lenders may require a capital expenditure reserve, which reduces the cash flow available for debt service. On your worksheet, show capex separately as a deduction after NOI, and ask the lender whether it will require a reserve. [1] Permanent lenders underwrite adjusted cash flow that includes reserves.

Model this deal and request financing

Run a refinance model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.

Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.

Open the refinance model

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. Wraith permanent loans