Preparing a guarantor information checklist without promising approval
A practical guide for commercial real estate sponsors to prepare a guarantor information checklist. Focuses on actionable evidence and understanding how the information affects the financing discussion, distinguishing source facts from assumptions.
A practical guide for commercial real estate sponsors to prepare a guarantor information checklist. Focuses on actionable evidence and understanding how the information affects the financing discussion, distinguishing source facts from assumptions.
This guide helps a commercial real estate sponsor prepare a guarantor information checklist. The task is to assemble the evidence a bank examiner or underwriter will use to evaluate the guarantor's financial condition and willingness to support the credit. The goal is to make the sponsor's own file ready for a productive financing discussion, not to guarantee a particular outcome.
Understanding why a guarantor matters to the lender
Bank supervisory guidance from the OCC explains that a guarantor can provide a secondary source of repayment that can favorably affect a credit's risk rating when the primary source of repayment becomes inadequate [1]. When the primary source is satisfactory, the guarantor's strength is supplemental in importance [1]. The underwriter will consider whether the guarantor has both the financial capacity and the willingness to provide support, and whether the guarantee is legally enforceable [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to record the guarantor's economic incentive in the project and any history of fulfilling previous obligations [1].
Preparing a verified liquidity and global cash flow workpaper
The OCC guidance states that guarantor liquidity should be verified by the bank [1]. A practical workpaper to prepare is a global cash flow analysis that includes income, liquidity, cash flow, contingent liabilities, and other relevant information [1]. The workpaper should document the guarantor's personal debt payments, property and income taxes, and living expenses [1]. A suggested way to organize this is to create a single-page summary that lists all sources of income, all recurring obligations, and a calculation of net free cash flow. The underwriter will use this to assess whether the guarantor has the financial capacity to fulfill the obligation if needed.
Identifying the total number and amount of outstanding guarantees
The OCC assessment for the guarantor should include consideration of the total number and amount of guarantees currently extended to all lenders [1]. This is to evaluate whether the guarantor has the financial capacity to fulfill the contingent claims that exist [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to ask the guarantor to list every guarantee they currently provide, including the lender name, original amount, current balance, and expiration date. This information helps the underwriter understand the guarantor's total contingent liability exposure.
Documenting the willingness to perform under guarantees
Examiners should consider whether a guarantor has demonstrated the willingness and ability to fulfill all current and previous obligations [1]. An important consideration is whether previously required performance under guarantees was voluntary or the result of legal or other actions by the lender to enforce the guarantee [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to gather any correspondence or documentation showing how the guarantor responded to prior requests for support. This could include payment records, emails, or letters from previous lenders. The underwriter will use this to assess the guarantor's reliability.
Collecting organizational documents and ownership structure
A suggested way to prepare is to gather the operating agreement, partnership agreement, or articles of incorporation for the borrowing entity, as well as any documents that show the ownership chain. This helps the lender understand who controls the entity and who is ultimately responsible for the debt. The OCC guidance notes that a guarantor's unpledged assets should not be considered a substitute for project equity [1].
Distinguishing the guarantee type and its limitations
Some guarantees may be limited in nature, such as interest only, construction completion only, partial principal, reduced in amount, or released during the loan term as certain conditions are met [1]. The bank should monitor compliance with these terms [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to identify what type of guarantee is being offered and record any limitations or conditions. The underwriter will need to understand whether the guarantee is full or limited, and what triggers the guarantor's obligation.
Reconciling the rent roll and trailing twelve months of operating statements
A suggested way to prepare is to compare the current rent roll (a snapshot of current tenants and rents) with the trailing twelve months (T-12) of operating statements, which show historical income and expenses. The T-12 will show gross rent, collected income, net operating income, capital expenditures, debt service, and equity cash flow over the past twelve months. The underwriter will use this to assess the property's cash flow and the borrower's ability to service the debt.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a rent roll and a trailing twelve months of operating statements? A rent roll is a snapshot of the property's current tenants, lease terms, and rents. A trailing twelve months (T-12) of operating statements shows the actual income and expenses for each of the past twelve months. The T-12 will show historical trends in occupancy, rent collections, and operating costs, while the rent roll shows the current status.
Does a guarantor's personal liquidity guarantee loan approval? No. Bank supervisory guidance states that a guarantor's unpledged assets should not be considered a substitute for project equity [1]. The underwriter will evaluate the guarantor's financial condition as part of a comprehensive analysis that includes the property's cash flow, the borrower's capacity, and the collateral value.
What should I do if the guarantor has a history of not responding to previous lenders? The OCC guidance states that banks with sound credit administration processes demonstrate continuous and diligent efforts to collect information, even when borrowers or guarantors do not respond [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to document any prior instances and the reasons for the lack of response. The underwriter will consider this when assessing willingness to perform.
To discuss a specific property and business plan, send the property details, the business plan, and the amount and timing of the capital you need. Submission is a preliminary request, not an engagement or lender submission.
Run the numbers on your deal
Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).