Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Preparing a schedule of contingent liabilities for a lender discussion

A practical guide to documenting every off-balance-sheet obligation that could affect a sponsor's capacity to repay, so lenders can underwrite the real risk rather than the apparent one.

Source: CodexTopic: Sponsor equity and liquidity1089 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A practical guide to documenting every off-balance-sheet obligation that could affect a sponsor's capacity to repay, so lenders can underwrite the real risk rather than the apparent one.

Why contingent liabilities matter in underwriting

Lenders evaluate a borrower's and guarantor's global cash flow, not just the cash flow from the subject property. Underwriting includes required and discretionary cash flows from all activities and any actual or contingent liabilities and their potential effect on repayment capacity [1]. A contingent liability is an obligation that becomes payable only if a future event occurs. Common examples include guarantees on other loans, unresolved litigation, pending tax assessments, and obligations under standby commitments. The OCC's guidance directs examiners to consider whether a guarantor has the financial capacity to fulfill contingent claims that exist, including the total number and amount of guarantees currently extended to all lenders [1]. Preparing a schedule of these items in advance allows a lender to see the complete picture rather than discovering obligations piecemeal during underwriting.

What to include in the schedule

Create a single workpaper that lists every contingent liability for each borrowing entity, guarantor, and key principal. For each item, record the following:

  • The type of obligation (e.g., loan guarantee, letter of credit, performance bond, pending lawsuit, tax contingency, unfunded pension obligation)
  • The entity or person who is obligated
  • The maximum potential amount for which the party could be liable
  • The trigger event that would cause the liability to become actual (e.g., default by the primary obligor, adverse judgment, final tax assessment)
  • The estimated probability or timeframe of the trigger event (your own assessment, not a guarantee)
  • Any collateral or reserves that would offset the liability if it were triggered

Do not limit the schedule to real estate–related items. Include personal guarantees on business loans, obligations under partnership or LLC operating agreements, and any indemnities provided in acquisition or service contracts.

How the schedule affects the financing discussion

A lender uses this schedule to stress-test the borrower's and guarantor's capacity to service the proposed debt. The OCC's handbook states that the analysis should consider required and discretionary cash flows from all activities and any actual or contingent liabilities [1]. If a contingent liability is large and likely to be triggered, the lender may require additional equity, a larger interest reserve, or a lower loan amount. Conversely, a well-documented schedule showing that contingent liabilities are remote, fully reserved, or offset by other assets can strengthen the borrower's case for more favorable terms.

Distinguishing source facts from assumptions

The OCC material cited here is bank supervisory guidance, not a rule binding every borrower or nonbank lender [1]. The guidance describes what examiners review in bank portfolios; it does not prescribe what every lender must require from a borrower. However, many lenders follow similar principles in their own underwriting. When you prepare the schedule, label your own probability estimates and reserve assumptions clearly as your analysis, not as lender policy. If you rely on a legal opinion to estimate the likelihood of a lawsuit outcome, state that basis. Do not present the schedule as a guarantee that no other contingent liabilities exist; instead, represent it as a good-faith effort to identify all known obligations.

Suggested worksheet: contingent liability register

Use the following column headings to build your register. This is a suggested way to prepare information, not a mandatory lender process.

  • Obligor name
  • Obligation type
  • Maximum amount
  • Trigger event
  • Estimated likelihood (low / medium / high, with brief rationale)
  • Offset / reserve (describe any collateral, insurance, or cash reserve that would reduce the net exposure)
  • Last review date

Complete the register for each entity and each guarantor. Update it at least quarterly or whenever a new contingent obligation is incurred.

Reconciling the schedule with financial statements

A balance sheet may not show contingent liabilities unless they meet accounting rules for recognition. Your schedule is a supplement to the financial statements, not a replacement. Compare the schedule to notes in audited financials, tax return disclosures, and any loan applications or credit agreements the borrower has signed. If the financial statements are on an accrual basis, the contingent liability may already be reflected as a provision or reserve; note that in the schedule. If the statements are on a cash basis, the contingent liability is unlikely to appear at all, so the schedule becomes the primary document.

Addressing standby commitments and take-out risk

If the proposed financing involves a construction loan that relies on a standby or forward commitment for permanent take-out, the contingent liability schedule should include the terms of that commitment. The OCC handbook notes that standby commitments may be structured to dissuade the borrower from exercising them, and that lenders typically review the likelihood that the project will meet the criteria for funding and investigate the willingness and ability of the issuer to fund [1]. Record the commitment's conditions, fee structure, and any performance criteria such as lease-up thresholds or minimum rental rates. If the commitment is from a nonbank entity such as a life insurance company, include that entity's creditworthiness in your assessment.

FAQs

How far back should I go when identifying contingent liabilities?

There is no fixed lookback period. Identify all currently existing obligations, regardless of when they were incurred. If a guarantee was signed five years ago and has not been released, include it. If a lawsuit was filed three years ago and is still pending, include it. For expired or released obligations, note the release date and keep a record in case the lender asks.

Should I include personal guarantees on consumer debt?

Yes, if the guarantor is an individual whose personal financial capacity is being evaluated. Personal guarantees on mortgages, car loans, or credit lines are contingent liabilities if the primary obligor is someone else. For the guarantor's own debt, that is a direct liability, not contingent, and should appear on the guarantor's personal financial statement instead.

What if I cannot estimate the probability of a contingent liability being triggered?

State that you cannot estimate it and explain why. For example, a lawsuit in early discovery may have an unknown outcome. Lenders prefer an honest acknowledgment over a speculative number. The lender may then request a legal opinion or adjust its own underwriting assumptions accordingly.


If you are preparing a financing request and would like help structuring the contingent liability schedule or any other part of the loan package, send the property, the business plan, and the capital you need to contact@wraithre.com. Submission is a preliminary request, not an engagement or lender submission.

Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook
  2. Wraith commercial real estate debt