How selling costs affect an apartment model's net sale proceeds
A practical guide to identifying, documenting, and discussing selling costs with lenders, including an evidence checklist for the borrower's file.
A practical guide to identifying, documenting, and discussing selling costs with lenders, including an evidence checklist for the borrower's file.
When you finance a residential apartment development—whether a condominium building or a for-sale multifamily project—selling costs directly affect the net proceeds available to repay debt. Lenders treat these costs differently from hard and soft construction costs, and the distinction matters for your loan request.
This guide explains how selling costs appear in a lender's underwriting, what evidence you can prepare, and how to discuss the information with your lender. It includes a concrete worksheet you can build for your project.
What selling costs are and why they are separated
Selling costs are the expenses incurred to market and close the sale of individual units. Typical items include brokerage commissions, closing costs, marketing and advertising, model unit staging, and sales office expenses. [1] The OCC's Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook lists selling costs such as brokerage commissions and other closing costs as items that should not be included in the construction budget, as they are to be funded out of sales proceeds.
Lenders separate selling costs from construction costs because the two have different risk profiles. Construction costs are incurred to create the asset; selling costs are incurred to convert that asset into cash. If a project stops before completion, the construction budget determines how much is needed to finish. Selling costs only become due when a sale occurs.
How selling costs affect net sale proceeds
Net sale proceeds are the cash remaining after paying all costs of a sale. For a lender underwriting a construction loan, projected net proceeds from unit sales are a primary source of repayment. [1] The OCC handbook notes that lower than projected selling prices, slow sales, or excessive inventories relative to sales indicate the borrower may have difficulty repaying the loan.
When you estimate net proceeds, you subtract selling costs from the gross sale price. Underestimating those costs inflates projected net proceeds, potentially creating a repayment gap. Overestimating may suggest a need for more equity or a lower loan amount.
Preparing a selling costs evidence worksheet
A concrete document you can prepare is a selling costs evidence worksheet. This is not a lender-mandated form; it is a suggested way to organize information for your file and your discussion with the lender. Build it as a simple table or spreadsheet with the following columns:
- Unit identifier (unit number or model type)
- Projected gross sale price
- Itemized selling costs (commission rate, closing cost estimate, marketing allocation, other fees)
- Total selling costs per unit
- Projected net sale proceeds (gross price minus total selling costs)
- Source of each cost estimate (broker quote, prior project actual, market survey)
For each cost item, record the basis of your estimate. Note whether your brokerage commission rate is based on a signed listing agreement, a broker's written proposal, or a market survey of comparable projects. [1] The OCC handbook expects budgets to be reviewed for reasonableness, and your documented sources help demonstrate that.
Distinguishing selling costs from other project costs
Selling costs differ from soft costs such as developer fees, leasing expenses, or management fees. [1] The OCC handbook states soft costs may be included in the construction budget if reasonable compared to third-party costs, but selling costs should not be included. Similarly, interest or preferred returns payable to equity partners should not be in the construction budget.
When preparing your sources and uses of funds, place selling costs in a separate line item under "uses funded from sales proceeds." This clarifies to the lender that these costs do not consume construction loan funds.
Discussing selling costs with your lender
When you present your project to a lender, be prepared to explain your selling cost assumptions. The lender will want to see:
- A list of all selling costs you anticipate
- The basis for each estimate
- How the costs compare to market norms for similar projects in your area
- Any contingencies you have built in for cost increases or slower sales
[1] The OCC handbook discusses that appropriate deductions and discounts for condominiums typically include holding costs, marketing costs, and entrepreneurial profit during the sales absorption period. Your selling costs worksheet should align with these categories.
How to reconcile your worksheet with operating history
If you have prior projects, compare your actual selling costs from those projects to your current estimates. Identify differences in commission rates, closing cost structures, or marketing strategies. If this is your first project, research comparable recent projects in your market. [1] The OCC handbook mentions that the bank should monitor factors such as housing prices, inventory, and consumer confidence that could affect marketing and selling.
Record the date and source of any market data you use. If conditions change between your worksheet and the lender's underwriting, you can update the comparison.
FAQs
Should I include selling costs in my construction loan budget?
No. [1] The OCC handbook lists selling costs such as brokerage commissions and other closing costs as items that should not be included in the construction budget, as they are to be funded out of sales proceeds. Include them in a separate schedule of projected sales costs.
What happens if actual selling costs are higher than I estimated?
Higher selling costs reduce your net sale proceeds. [1] If proceeds are lower than projected, the borrower may have difficulty repaying the loan. Discuss with your lender whether a contingency for selling costs is appropriate and how it would be funded.
Does a lender require a signed listing agreement before closing a construction loan?
Not necessarily for the initial loan closing, but the lender will want to see your selling cost assumptions supported by evidence. [1] The OCC handbook notes that for presales, the bank should obtain documentation of binding sales contracts and buyer financing commitments. For cost estimates, documented market research or broker quotes are typical.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a multifamily acquisition or value-add model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).