How to enter acquisition closing costs without double-counting purchase uses
A practical guide for sponsors to distinguish acquisition closing costs from purchase price uses, prepare a clear sources-and-uses schedule, and avoid the common double-counting error that can confuse lender underwriting.
A practical guide for sponsors to distinguish acquisition closing costs from purchase price uses, prepare a clear sources-and-uses schedule, and avoid the common double-counting error that can confuse lender underwriting.
Why closing costs and purchase uses are separate categories
When preparing a sources-and-uses schedule for a commercial real estate acquisition, it is important to separate the purchase price from closing costs. The purchase price represents the amount the seller receives for the property, while closing costs include fees, prorations, reserves, and prepaid items the borrower pays to complete the transaction. Combining these into a single figure makes it difficult for lenders to verify how much capital is allocated to the asset versus transaction expenses. [1] The OCC supervisory guidance for construction loans emphasizes the need for a detailed budget identifying all costs funded by the loan. Although this guidance is specific to construction loans, the principle of clear cost identification is equally relevant for acquisition financings: lenders need transparency on what each dollar is funding.
Understanding hard equity versus acquisition costs
Hard equity refers to the borrower's tangible investment in the property, such as cash, unencumbered real estate (e.g., land), and materials for improvements. [1] Closing costs—such as lender fees, title insurance, legal fees, appraisal costs, environmental reports, and survey charges—are generally considered transaction expenses rather than hard equity. While the OCC handbook defines hard equity, it does not provide an exhaustive list of what is excluded. Therefore, these closing costs are typically treated as separate from the borrower's equity contribution. This distinction helps lenders assess whether the borrower's equity meets supervisory loan-to-value guidelines or internal requirements. [1] The Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate Lending note that when a loan is renewed or refinanced without advancing new funds, reasonable closing costs may be included without triggering supervisory loan-to-value limits, implying that closing costs are treated separately from the principal loan amount for that specific purpose.
Creating a clear sources-and-uses schedule
A practical approach is to prepare a two-column schedule. On the left, list all sources of funds: senior loan amount, mezzanine or subordinate debt, borrower's cash equity, and any seller carryback financing. On the right, organize uses into two sub-groups:
- Purchase price: contract price for the property, any assumed existing debt, and seller credits reducing cash due at closing.
- Closing costs: lender origination fees, underwriting and processing fees, title insurance and escrow charges, legal fees for borrower's counsel, appraisal and third-party report costs, survey, environmental assessments, recording taxes and transfer stamps, prepaid interest or interest reserve funding, property insurance premiums, property tax prorations, and required reserve deposits for repairs or tenant improvements.
The sum of these two sub-groups should equal total sources. Double-counting errors occur when a cost, such as a lender fee, is included both within the purchase price and again in closing costs, or when a tenant improvement reserve is listed as a use but also deducted from net operating income in the pro forma.
Reconciling rent roll and trailing twelve months (T-12) to the acquisition budget
For income-producing properties, sponsors should provide a current rent roll and a trailing twelve months (T-12) of operating statements. The rent roll is a snapshot of current tenants, unit sizes, lease terms, base rent, and concessions. The T-12 shows actual income and expenses over the past year. Lenders compare these documents to assess whether recent property performance supports the projected net operating income in the pro forma. [1] The OCC handbook notes that construction loan files typically include pro forma projections on property cash flows. While this guidance is specific to construction loans, lenders for acquisition financings often apply similar scrutiny to ensure revenue and expense assumptions are grounded in actual operating history. When comparing the rent roll to the T-12, sponsors should note that the rent roll reflects current contract rent, whereas The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis, including vacancy, credit losses, and concessions. A significant gap between gross rent on the rent roll and collected income on the T-12 may indicate overly optimistic pro forma assumptions.
Differentiating net operating income, debt service, and equity cash flow
Net operating income (NOI) is the property's effective gross income minus operating expenses, before debt service and capital expenditures. [1] The income approach to valuation converts expected future NOI into present value through direct capitalization or discounted cash-flow analysis. Lenders underwrite loans based on NOI rather than gross income. Sponsors should present a clear income waterfall: gross potential rent, less vacancy and credit loss, plus other income equals effective gross income. From this, subtract operating expenses—such as property management, utilities, repairs and maintenance, insurance, and real estate taxes—to arrive at NOI. Then show annual debt service (principal and interest) on the proposed loan. The remaining cash flow represents the equity return before capital expenditures. If capital expenditures or tenant improvement costs are included in the uses of funds at closing, they should appear in the sources-and-uses schedule and not be deducted again from NOI in the operating pro forma.
Identifying the reporting basis and reconciling periods
Financial statements for existing properties may be prepared on a cash or accrual basis. Sponsors should specify the accounting basis used and explain any material differences. For example, a cash-basis T-12 may show lower income in months when rent was collected late, while an accrual-basis statement records income when earned. Lenders prefer consistent period-over-period comparisons. [1] The OCC handbook advises reviewing budgets and schedules to determine whether they realistically reflect costs and timelines. Budgets lacking detail or appearing overly optimistic should be questioned. Sponsors can address this by clearly labeling the accounting method and reconciling timing differences between the rent roll and T-12.
Preparing a closing cost evidence checklist
Sponsors can prepare a closing cost evidence checklist—a table listing each expected closing cost, estimated amount, vendor or payee, and supporting source document. For example, lender fees are supported by the term sheet or loan commitment; appraisal costs by the appraisal invoice; title insurance by the title company's quote; and legal fees by the borrower's counsel engagement letter. Sharing this checklist with the lender early demonstrates that closing costs are reasonable and supported. [1] The OCC handbook highlights the importance of reviewing budgets to assess appropriateness and reasonableness. A closing cost checklist serves a similar purpose for acquisition transactions.
Consulting the lender on closing cost policies
Lenders vary in how they treat closing costs. Some allow financing a portion of closing costs within the loan amount; others require payment from equity. Origination fee structures and caps on specific costs like legal fees or third-party reports also differ. Sponsors should ask lenders directly which closing costs can be included in the loan, which must be paid from equity, and any applicable caps. [1] The Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate Lending note that loans renewed or refinanced without advancing new funds may include reasonable closing costs without affecting supervisory loan-to-value limits, indicating that closing costs are considered separately from the principal loan amount in that context. Sponsors should not assume uniform lender policies.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a rent roll and a T-12?
A rent roll is a current snapshot of tenants, lease terms, and contractual rents. A T-12 is a historical report of actual income and expenses over the trailing twelve months. The rent roll shows expected rent; The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis. Comparing them helps lenders evaluate income stability.
Can the interest reserve be included in closing costs?
An interest reserve funds loan interest during construction or lease-up periods. It is a use of funds but not typically classified as a closing cost. It should be listed separately in the uses column of the sources-and-uses schedule, with details on the amount and coverage period.
Does the closing cost evidence checklist replace the lender's documentation requirements?
No. The checklist helps sponsors organize information for the lender but does not replace the lender's underwriting requirements. Lenders may request additional documentation. The checklist facilitates timely responses to lender inquiries about closing cost estimates.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a multifamily acquisition or value-add model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).