Documenting who may provide information during commercial lender diligence
A practical guide for sponsors to prepare a diligence contact list and information authority matrix, reducing closing delays and miscommunication with lenders.
A practical guide for sponsors to prepare a diligence contact list and information authority matrix, reducing closing delays and miscommunication with lenders.
During commercial real estate financing, lenders will request information from many parties: the sponsor, property manager, leasing agent, third-party report providers, and sometimes tenants or contractors. Without clear documentation of who is authorized to provide what, the process can stall, or conflicting information may surface. This guide explains how to prepare a single document that controls information flow during lender diligence, based on the lender's need to verify the sponsor's control and the property's performance.
Information authority matrix
The core document to prepare is an information authority matrix. This is a simple table or list that names each person or firm that may be contacted by the lender, the specific information they are authorized to provide, and their relationship to the borrowing entity. For example, the property manager may provide rent rolls and operating statements, but not the sponsor's financial statements. The leasing agent may provide lease abstracts and market comparables, but not tenant financials. The matrix should also list which lender representatives may contact each party, and whether prior sponsor approval is needed for each contact. This document is not a legal agreement, but a suggested way to prepare information for the lender's diligence process. It should be reviewed with the actual lender to confirm it meets their requirements.
Distinguishing information roles
It is important to distinguish who provides what type of information. The sponsor controls the borrowing entity and provides financial statements, organizational documents, and the business plan. The property manager provides operational data: rent rolls, trailing twelve months of operating statements (T-12), and lease information. The appraiser and other third-party report providers (environmental, engineering, zoning) are typically engaged by the lender or by the sponsor with lender approval, and they report directly to the lender. Tenants or contractors should not be contacted by the lender without the sponsor's prior consent, as this can disrupt operations. The matrix should clearly state that the lender must obtain sponsor approval before contacting tenants or contractors. This is a practical organizing step, not a mandatory lender process.
Timing of information requests
Lenders request information at different stages: during initial underwriting, during the application period, and during closing. The matrix should specify when each party may be contacted. For example, the property manager may be contacted during underwriting to verify rent rolls, but the appraiser may only be contacted after the lender has accepted the engagement. The sponsor should record the expected timing of each information request in the matrix, and update it as the process moves forward. This helps avoid surprises and ensures the lender has access to the right information at the right time. [1] notes that lenders typically investigate the willingness and ability of the issuer to fund for standby commitments, which may include contacting the issuer directly. The matrix should anticipate such contacts and designate who will respond.
Verifying the property's performance
A key part of lender diligence is verifying the property's income and expenses. The lender will compare the rent roll (a snapshot of current tenants and rents) with the T-12 (twelve historical months of income and expenses). These two documents have different timing: the rent roll shows current status, while the T-12 shows historical performance. Before comparing them, the sponsor should identify the reporting basis for the T-12 (cash or accrual) and reconcile periods to ensure the comparison is accurate. The matrix should name the person who can explain any differences, such as the property manager or accountant. The lender will also examine net operating income (NOI), capital expenditures (capex), debt service, and equity cash flow. The sponsor should prepare a reconciliation of these items, distinguishing gross rent from collected income, and showing how NOI is calculated. This is not a mandatory lender process, but a suggested way to prepare information that the lender will likely request. [1] discusses that underwriting includes analysis of the risk should a take-out commitment not be funded, which may require the lender to verify the property's performance against the commitment's criteria.
Third-party report coordination
Lenders require third-party reports such as appraisals, environmental site assessments, and engineering reports. The matrix should list each report, the provider, and who is authorized to communicate with the provider. For appraisals, the lender typically orders the report directly, but the sponsor may provide access to the property and historical data. The sponsor should identify a single point of contact for the appraiser to avoid conflicting instructions. [1] includes a checklist for evaluations that asks whether the evaluation describes the methods used to confirm the property's actual physical condition, and whether it includes evidence of a property inspection and photos. The sponsor should ensure the appraiser has access to the property and any relevant documents. The matrix should also note that the lender may contact the environmental consultant directly to clarify the scope of the inquiry, but the sponsor should be copied on such communications. This is a suggested way to organize the process, not a guarantee of environmental clearance or liability protection.
Sponsor financial information control
The sponsor's financial statements and organizational documents are sensitive. The matrix should specify who in the sponsor's organization is authorized to provide these documents to the lender. Typically, this is the sponsor's CFO, controller, or a designated finance officer. The matrix should also list any guarantors and their authorized representatives. The lender may request financial statements for the principals and guarantors, and the matrix should designate who will provide them. The sponsor should also prepare a schedule of real estate owned, which the lender may use to verify the sponsor's experience and financial capacity. [1] notes that the interagency guidelines recognize that appropriate LTV limits vary among individual loans, and that loans exceeding supervisory LTV limits may be appropriate based on support from other credit factors, including the sponsor's financial strength. The matrix should ensure that the lender can verify these factors through the designated contacts.
Documenting the authority
The information authority matrix should be signed by the sponsor's authorized representative and provided to the lender at the beginning of the diligence process. The sponsor should also keep a copy and update it if any contacts change. The matrix is not a legal document, but a practical tool to streamline communication and avoid confusion. It should be treated as a living document, reviewed at each stage of the financing. The sponsor should ask the actual lender if they have any specific requirements for information authority, and incorporate those into the matrix. This is a suggested way to prepare information, not a mandatory lender process.
Frequently asked questions
Can the lender contact my tenants directly? Only if you authorize it in the information authority matrix. Typically, lenders should not contact tenants without your prior consent, as it can disrupt operations. The matrix should state that tenant contact requires sponsor approval.
What if the property manager provides information that conflicts with my records? The matrix should designate you or your accountant as the person to reconcile any differences. The lender will compare the rent roll and T-12, and you should be prepared to explain any discrepancies.
Do I need a separate matrix for each lender? No, but you should review the matrix with each lender to confirm it meets their requirements. Some lenders may have specific preferences for who they contact and how.
We prepare the loan request, select lenders suited to the property and plan, and negotiate terms through closing. To begin, share the property, business plan, amount and timing. Visit our website to request financing.
Run the numbers on your deal
Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).