Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

How to distinguish requested, received and reviewed financing documents

A practical guide for commercial real estate sponsors on creating a document control workpaper that tracks what lenders ask for, what has been delivered, and what has been formally reviewed, with an actionable evidence checklist to prepare before approaching lenders.

Source: CodexTopic: Financing process and document control1503 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A practical guide for commercial real estate sponsors on creating a document control workpaper that tracks what lenders ask for, what has been delivered, and what has been formally reviewed, with an actionable evidence checklist to prepare before approaching lenders.

Document request, delivery and review as separate stages

A lender's initial request list is not a commitment to underwrite every item. The OCC handbook notes that banks typically maintain signed financial statements, operating statements, rent rolls, title insurance, recorded mortgages, leases, tenant estoppels, insurance policies, appraisals and evaluations in loan files [1]. This is a description of what banks aim to keep, not a mandatory checklist for every loan.

Your workpaper should have three columns: requested, received and reviewed. In the requested column, list what the lender asks for. In the received column, note what you have delivered. In the reviewed column, record only what the lender has formally acknowledged reviewing, such as through an appraisal review or a written underwriting comment.

The OCC handbook asks whether the bank has a check sheet to ensure required documents are received and on file [1]. You can create your own check sheet that mirrors this approach, but for your own tracking, not for the lender.

Rent roll and trailing twelve months: timing differences matter

For an existing property, lenders typically ask for a current rent roll and a trailing twelve months of operating statements, often called a T-12. These are different documents with different timing.

A current rent roll is a snapshot of the property's leases and occupancy as of a specific date. A T-12 is a historical report of income and expenses for each of the past twelve months. The rent roll shows who is renting, at what rate, and when leases expire. The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis and spent over time.

When comparing the two, you will likely see differences. The rent roll shows gross potential rent, while The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis after vacancies, concessions and bad debt. Do not assume these should match. Instead, prepare a reconciliation that explains the gap between gross rent on the rent roll and collected income on the T-12.

This reconciliation is a suggested workpaper you can prepare. It is not a standard lender form, but it shows you understand the property's cash flow.

Distinguishing income, expenses and cash flow layers

A common point of confusion is mixing gross rent, collected income, net operating income, capital expenditures, debt service and equity cash flow. Each layer serves a different purpose in the financing discussion.

Gross rent is the total potential rent if the property were fully occupied at market rates. Collected income is what actually came in after vacancies and collections. Net operating income is collected income minus operating expenses. Capital expenditures are major improvements that are not operating expenses. Debt service is the loan payments. Equity cash flow is what remains after all expenses and debt service.

When you present financial statements, identify the reporting basis. If your statements are on an accrual basis, say so. If they are on a cash basis, say that. The OCC handbook mentions signed financial statements for borrowers and guarantors, and operating statements and rent rolls for the property [1]. It does not prescribe cash or accrual. What matters is that you state the basis and reconcile any differences between periods.

Evidence checklist for the sponsor's file

Prepare a document control workpaper with the following items. For each, note the stage: requested, received or reviewed.

  • Signed financial statements for the borrowing entity and guarantors, with the reporting basis stated
  • Operating statements for the property for the most recent trailing twelve months, with a reconciliation to the rent roll
  • Current rent roll, dated and with lease expiration dates
  • Pro forma with assumptions clearly stated, such as rent growth, expense growth and vacancy rates
  • Sources and uses of funds table showing where the money comes from and where it goes
  • Development budget and schedule for construction loans, including contingency allowances
  • Title insurance policy, with property descriptions checked for consistency across mortgage, deed of trust, survey and tax statement
  • Copies of all leases and executed tenant estoppels
  • Insurance policies with loss payable clause to the lender, and proof of premium payment
  • Appraisal or evaluation, with the bank's review documented
  • Organizational documents for the borrowing entity
  • Sponsor's schedule of real estate owned

This checklist is based on items the OCC handbook describes as typically maintained in bank loan files [1]. It is not exhaustive, and your lender may ask for additional items.

Environmental considerations and the lender's due diligence

Environmental risk is part of the lender's underwriting. The OCC handbook asks whether the bank has procedures to identify, evaluate and monitor potential environmental risks, and to determine the extent of due diligence necessary to protect the bank's business interests [1].

This means the lender may request an environmental site assessment. The EPA inquiry guidance does not guarantee environmental clearance or liability protection. As a sponsor, you should be prepared to provide any environmental reports you already have, and to discuss any known issues.

Loan agreement and document review by counsel

The OCC handbook asks whether loan agreements and other documents are reviewed by counsel and other experts to confirm that improvement specifications conform to building codes, zoning, title restrictions, health regulations, environmental considerations and tenant leases [1].

This review is the lender's process, not yours. However, you should expect that your own counsel will also review the loan documents. The OCC handbook also asks whether the bank requires all change orders to be approved in writing by the bank, the permanent financier, the architect, prime tenants and the completion bonding company [1]. This is a bank policy question, not a requirement you must meet before applying.

Appraisal review and independence

The OCC handbook includes a series of questions about appraisal review processes, including whether the bank's policy requires every CRE appraisal to be reviewed and documented, and whether the reviewer is independent of loan production and collection functions [1].

These are questions the bank asks itself, not questions you answer. But you should know that the lender will order an appraisal and have it reviewed. The appraisal review may be outsourced. The OCC handbook asks whether the bank has procedures to evaluate the experience and competency of evaluators [1].

Your role is to provide accurate information about the property so the appraiser can do their work. Do not attempt to influence the appraisal value.

Post-closing document tracking

After closing, the OCC handbook asks whether there is a program of systematic follow-up to determine that all required documents are received, and whether a designated employee conducts a review after loan closing to determine whether all documents are properly drawn, executed and in the bank's files [1].

This is the lender's internal process. Your job is to keep your own copies of all signed documents and to confirm that the lender has everything they need.

How the document workpaper affects the financing discussion

When you present a clear workpaper showing what has been requested, received and reviewed, you demonstrate organization and reduce the lender's uncertainty. The OCC handbook emphasizes that the lender should have sufficient information to permit a fully informed credit decision [1]. By providing complete and well-organized documents, you help the lender reach that decision more efficiently.

A common mistake is to assume that delivering a document means the lender has reviewed it. The reviewed stage is separate. If the lender has not formally acknowledged reviewing a document, follow up. The OCC handbook asks whether the bank has a system to determine that taxes and insurance are being paid [1]. Similarly, you should have a system to track what has been reviewed.

Suggested workpaper format

Create a simple table with columns for document name, date requested, date received, date delivered to lender, and date lender acknowledged review. For each document, note any issues or missing information. This workpaper is for your internal use. It is not a lender form.

FAQs

What is the difference between a rent roll and a T-12?

A rent roll is a snapshot of current leases and occupancy as of a specific date. A T-12 is a historical report of income and expenses for each of the past twelve months. The rent roll shows gross potential rent, while The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis. Prepare a reconciliation between the two.

Do I need to provide financial statements on a cash basis?

Not necessarily. The OCC handbook mentions signed financial statements but does not prescribe cash or accrual basis [1]. State the reporting basis clearly and reconcile any differences between periods. What matters is consistency and clarity.

Should I prepare an appraisal review myself?

No. The appraisal review is the lender's responsibility. The OCC handbook asks whether the bank's policy requires every CRE appraisal to be reviewed and documented [1]. Your role is to provide accurate property information to the appraiser.


Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook
  2. Wraith commercial real estate debt