Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Documenting physical conditions that affect a property's financing story

A practical evidence checklist for sponsors to prepare physical condition documentation that supports the financing narrative, distinguishes source facts from assumptions, and addresses how conditions affect lender underwriting.

Source: CodexTopic: Valuation and collateral evidence1218 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A practical evidence checklist for sponsors to prepare physical condition documentation that supports the financing narrative, distinguishes source facts from assumptions, and addresses how conditions affect lender underwriting.

When you ask a lender to finance a commercial property, the physical condition of that asset is part of the story the loan request tells. Lenders evaluate collateral partly by what they can see, inspect, and verify about the building's systems, structure, and site. The OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook notes that examiners may classify loans as doubtful when "collateral values that are uncertain due to a lack of comparables in an inactive market, pending changes such as zoning classification, environmental issues, or the pending resolution of legal issues that could affect the realization of value in a sale" [1]. Physical conditions that are undocumented, unresolved, or ambiguous can create that uncertainty. This guide gives you a concrete evidence checklist to prepare, explains how each category of condition affects the financing discussion, and helps you distinguish what you know from what you assume.

The physical condition evidence checklist

Prepare a single document, which you can call the Physical Condition Summary. For each item below, record the evidence you have and note any gaps. Do not assume a condition is fine because no one has complained. The goal is to show the lender what you know and what you are still investigating.

  • Structural systems: foundation, framing, roof structure. Record the date and type of the most recent structural inspection or engineering report. If none exists, state that.
  • Building envelope: windows, exterior walls, roofing membrane. Note any active leaks, past repairs, and the age of the roof.
  • Mechanical, electrical, and plumbing (MEP): HVAC units, boilers, chillers, electrical panels, plumbing risers. Record the age, maintenance records, and any deferred maintenance.
  • Life safety systems: fire alarms, sprinklers, emergency lighting, exits. Note the last inspection date and any outstanding code violations.
  • Environmental conditions: asbestos, lead, mold, soil contamination, underground storage tanks. Attach any Phase I or Phase II environmental site assessments. The OCC handbook treats "environmental issues" as a factor that can make collateral value uncertain [1].
  • Access and site conditions: parking, sidewalks, loading docks, easements, encroachments. Record any title exceptions or survey issues.
  • Zoning and land use: current zoning classification, any pending rezoning, variances, or non-conforming uses. The OCC handbook specifically lists "pending changes such as zoning classification" as a circumstance that may warrant a doubtful loan classification [1].

How physical conditions affect the financing discussion

Physical conditions affect three parts of the underwriting: collateral value, loan-to-value (LTV) ratio, and the borrower's ability to execute the business plan. The OCC real estate lending standards recognize that certain factors may outweigh the need to apply supervisory LTV limits, including loans guaranteed or insured by the U.S. government or its agencies, loans backed by the full faith and credit of a state government, loans guaranteed or insured by a state, municipal, or local government (provided certain conditions are met), loans sold without recourse, and certain restructurings [1]. For most transactions, the lender will rely on an appraised value that reflects the property's condition. Deferred maintenance or unaddressed environmental issues can reduce the appraised value, which in turn reduces the maximum loan amount the lender can offer under its own LTV policy. The OCC handbook also notes that "underwriting analyses that fail to consider possible stressed market conditions" and "projections that rely on speculative or unrealistic assumptions relative to current market conditions" are examples of underwriting weaknesses that may be indicative of credit deterioration [1]. Physical conditions that are ignored or assumed away in the pro forma are a form of unrealistic assumption.

Distinguishing source facts from assumptions

The OCC handbook is supervisory guidance for banks, not a set of rules that binds every borrower or nonbank lender. It describes what examiners look for when evaluating a bank's real estate lending practices [1]. When you prepare your Physical Condition Summary, label each piece of evidence as one of the following:

  • Fact: a documented observation, such as a roof age from a manufacturer's label or a Phase I report date.
  • Assumption: a statement you believe to be true without supporting evidence, such as "the HVAC seems fine."
  • Pending: an issue under investigation, such as a zoning variance application or an environmental assessment in progress.

Do not present assumptions as facts. If you have no inspection report, say so. Lenders prefer a candid gap to a confident guess.

Preparing the workpaper: the physical condition summary

Create a single-page table or list with three columns: Condition Category, Evidence On Hand, and Gap or Assumption. For example:

  • Structural systems: 2021 engineering report, no active issues. Gap: no report on the roof trusses.
  • Roof: replaced in 2019, manufacturer warranty on file. No gaps.
  • Environmental: Phase I from 2020, no recognized environmental conditions. Gap: no vapor intrusion assessment.
  • Zoning: current zoning permits current use. Pending: variance application for additional signage.

This workpaper is not a substitute for a property condition report or a Phase I, but it shows the lender that you have thought systematically about the property's physical story.

Addressing conditions that affect the business plan

If a physical condition could delay or increase the cost of your business plan, describe it in the loan request. For example, if you plan to renovate and the building has asbestos, include the abatement cost and timeline in your sources and uses. The OCC handbook notes that "borrower requests for additional financing due to unanticipated costs or expenses" and "deterioration in the performance of the borrower's other properties or businesses" are signs of credit risk [1]. If you identify a condition early and plan for it, you reduce the risk of an unanticipated request later.

Three frequently asked questions

Should I get a full property condition assessment before approaching a lender?

Not necessarily. A property condition assessment (PCA) can cost several thousand dollars and may not be needed until the lender requires it. Instead, prepare your own Physical Condition Summary using existing documents, your own walk-through observations, and any reports you already have. When you submit the loan request, note which conditions you have documented and which you have not. The lender will tell you if a PCA is required for its underwriting.

Does a Phase I environmental site assessment guarantee the property is clean?

No. A Phase I identifies recognized environmental conditions (RECs) based on historical use and site reconnaissance, but it does not include sampling or testing. The OCC handbook treats environmental issues as a factor that can make collateral value uncertain, but a Phase I is one piece of evidence, not a guarantee [1]. If the Phase I identifies a REC, the lender may require a Phase II (soil or groundwater testing) before closing.

What if I find a condition that reduces the property's value?

Disclose it. Lenders underwrite to the risk they know, not the risk they discover later. If you disclose a condition and explain how you plan to address it—through a reserve, a repair budget, or a price adjustment—the lender can factor it into the loan structure. Hiding a condition can lead to a denial or a loan classification issue later. The OCC handbook's discussion of doubtful classifications shows that specific circumstances such as pending zoning changes or environmental issues are what concern examiners [1].

Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook
  2. Wraith commercial real estate debt