Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

How to distinguish as-is value from stabilized value in a financing package

A practical evidence checklist for sponsors preparing a financing package that involves a property not yet at stabilized occupancy, explaining how each value type affects underwriting discussions and what source facts to separate from assumptions.

Source: CodexTopic: Valuation and collateral evidence1204 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A practical evidence checklist for sponsors preparing a financing package that involves a property not yet at stabilized occupancy, explaining how each value type affects underwriting discussions and what source facts to separate from assumptions.

When you prepare a financing package for a property that is under construction, being renovated, or still leasing up, you will encounter two distinct value concepts: as-is value and as-stabilized value. Lenders use these differently depending on the stage of the property and the business plan. Confusing them or mixing assumptions with facts can slow down underwriting. This guide explains how to distinguish them, what evidence to prepare, and how each affects the financing discussion.

What as-is and as-stabilized values mean in practice

For a construction loan, the appraisal should include a prospective market value upon completion (as-complete) and upon stabilization (as-stabilized) [1]. For an existing building that is partially leased or vacant, the as-is value is the starting point, and the as-stabilized value shows the potential after the business plan is executed. Lenders may use either value for the secured loan-to-value (SLTV) calculation depending on the property stage: as-is for raw land or stabilized properties, as-completed for owner-occupied or preleased construction, and as-stabilized for existing properties not yet stabilized or construction not preleased to stabilized levels [1].

Evidence checklist for as-is value

Record the actual net operating income (NOI) from the T-12: gross potential rent, minus vacancy and collection loss, plus other income, minus operating expenses. Do not use a pro forma NOI for as-is value. The as-is value is derived from actual, historical NOI, capitalized at a market cap rate, or from a discounted cash-flow analysis that reflects the current income stream and expected changes [1]. If the property is not stabilized, the discounted cash-flow method is more appropriate because it accounts for future fluctuations [1].

Evidence checklist for as-stabilized value

For as-stabilized value, you need a pro forma that shows the projected stabilized NOI. The pro forma must include the assumptions behind it: the expected stabilized occupancy level, the projected rental rates per square foot or per unit, the lease-up timeline (how many months to reach stabilization), and the operating expenses at stabilization. The cap rate used to capitalize the stabilized NOI should be supported by comparable sales or market surveys. The discount rate for a discounted cash-flow analysis should reflect reasonable investor return expectations [1].

If the property is being redeveloped to a different use, include the cost of demolition and site preparation in the analysis [1]. For construction loans, the appraisal will typically provide both as-complete and as-stabilized values. Your package should reconcile the two: show the total development cost, the as-complete value, and the as-stabilized value, and explain any gap.

How each value affects the financing discussion

Lenders use the appropriate value for the SLTV calculation. If you are borrowing for a construction project that is not preleased to stabilized levels, the as-stabilized value is typically used [1]. That means the lender is lending against the projected stabilized value, not the current as-is value. The loan amount will be a percentage of that as-stabilized value, and the lender will require that the project be feasible: that the as-complete value (or as-stabilized value) exceeds the total cost plus a margin.

For a bridge loan on a partially leased building, the lender may use as-is value for the initial advance but allow for future draws or a higher advance rate as occupancy increases toward stabilization. The debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) is calculated on the actual NOI, not the pro forma, until the property stabilizes. Lenders will want to see that the current income covers the debt service, or that the sponsor has sufficient liquidity to cover any shortfall during the lease-up period.

Separating source facts from assumptions

The rent roll and T-12 are factual historical documents. The pro forma is an assumption-based projection. Label every number in the pro forma with its source: market rent comparables, expense benchmarks from similar properties, or the appraiser's estimate. The cap rate and discount rate are assumptions, not facts, but they should be supported by market evidence [1]. If the appraiser uses a discounted cash-flow analysis, the assumptions about lease-up timing, rental growth, and exit cap rate should be clearly stated and compared to historical data.

Do not equate a cap rate with a debt constant. The cap rate converts NOI to value; the debt constant is the annual debt service divided by the loan amount. They are different concepts and should not be used interchangeably.

Suggested worksheet: value reconciliation table

Prepare a simple table with three columns: value type, source of NOI, and cap rate or discount rate used. Rows: as-is value (based on T-12 actual NOI, cap rate from recent sales of comparable stabilized properties or discounted cash-flow analysis), as-complete value (based on projected NOI at completion, before lease-up, if applicable), and as-stabilized value (based on pro forma stabilized NOI, cap rate from market). For each row, note whether the value is used for SLTV, for debt sizing, or for feasibility analysis. This worksheet helps you and the lender see exactly what each value represents and where assumptions enter.

How to present the package to a lender or debt arranger

Label each document clearly. For the pro forma, state the occupancy level you are projecting and the timeline to reach it. If you have an appraisal, include the page that shows as-is, as-complete, and as-stabilized values. Lenders quote on what they are given, so complete and clear evidence improves the quality of indicative terms [2].

Can I use as-stabilized value for a loan on a vacant building?

Yes, but only if the loan is structured for the property to achieve stabilization, such as a construction or bridge loan. The lender will typically use as-stabilized value for the SLTV calculation if the property is not preleased to stabilized levels [1]. The loan will be sized on that value, and the lender will require a feasible plan to reach stabilization, including sufficient reserves or sponsor liquidity to cover carrying costs during lease-up.

What if my actual NOI is negative during lease-up?

Negative NOI is common during lease-up or renovation. The as-is value may be very low or even negative using direct capitalization, but the discounted cash-flow method can capture the future positive income [1]. Lenders will want to see that the project is feasible overall: that the as-stabilized value exceeds total cost, and that the sponsor has the liquidity to fund the negative cash flow until stabilization. Include a sources-and-uses statement that shows how the negative period is funded.

Does the appraisal always provide both as-is and as-stabilized values?

For construction loans, the appraisal should include a prospective market value upon completion and upon stabilization [1]. For existing properties, the appraiser may provide as-is value and, if the property is not stabilized, a prospective as-stabilized value. If the property is already stabilized, only as-is value is needed. Check the appraisal scope and ask the appraiser to include both if your business plan involves a transition to stabilization.


If you have a property and a business plan, send us the property details, the plan, the amount needed, and the timing. We will tell you how we would approach it.

Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook
  2. Wraith commercial real estate debt