What to verify before relying on a model's sale proceeds calculation
A concrete checklist for commercial real estate sponsors to verify the assumptions behind a financing model's projected sale proceeds, distinguishing source-backed facts from sponsor assumptions before submitting a preliminary package.
A concrete checklist for commercial real estate sponsors to verify the assumptions behind a financing model's projected sale proceeds, distinguishing source-backed facts from sponsor assumptions before submitting a preliminary package.
When you build a financing scenario, the sale proceeds line can feel like the most reliable number in the model. In practice, that number depends on a chain of assumptions about absorption speed, release pricing, and equity timing. Verifying those assumptions before you submit a preliminary package helps you present a credible request and avoid surprises when lender underwriting reviews the same inputs.
This guide walks through a specific evidence checklist you can prepare alongside your scenario. The goal is to document what you know, flag what you are assuming, and identify where bank supervisory guidance provides a framework for how lenders typically evaluate those assumptions.
Identify the absorption rate your model assumes
Your model likely projects when units sell and when proceeds arrive. The expected absorption rate is an important consideration when establishing limits on the construction of speculative units [1]. If your model assumes 10 units sell per quarter but local market data shows 6 per quarter for comparable properties, the proceeds timing shifts. Record the absorption rate you used and note whether it comes from an appraisal, market study, or your own estimate. Bank supervisory guidance notes that for multiple-unit loans, the maximum number of units financed should consider the tenor and anticipated rate of unit sales [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to compare your assumed rate to any recent absorption study you have for the property or a comparable nearby development.
Document the release price mechanics in your deal
If your financing involves releasing liens as units sell, the model's proceeds are tied to how much you must pay per unit to release the bank's lien. Bank supervisory guidance describes release price acceleration: the amount required to release a unit lien is typically some multiple of the unit's proportional share of the total value of the entire project [1]. The guidance provides an example where the release price is calculated based on the proportionate debt per unit [1]. Your model may assume a simple per-unit payoff, but the actual loan agreement likely specifies an accelerated release price. Compare your model's per-unit proceeds against what an accelerated release formula would require. If your model shows healthy surplus but the release price consumes most of each sale, that changes the cash flow picture. Ask the actual lender what release price formula they use for similar projects.
Confirm the equity contribution timing in your budget
Your model's proceeds calculation may assume you can reinvest sale proceeds into the next phase. Bank supervisory guidance states that for a construction project, the budget should reflect sufficient funds for completion, and approving a loan to finance partial construction without committed funds for completion (either from the bank or an external source) is generally considered a liberal underwriting practice [1]. If your model relies on early unit sales to fund later construction, verify whether those proceeds arrive early enough to cover the next phase's costs. A suggested way to prepare is to create a simple timeline showing when equity is contributed, when construction costs are paid, and when sale proceeds arrive. If there is a gap, note how you plan to cover it. Prudent policies clearly state requirements for borrower equity, including the amounts required, the acceptable types and sources of equity, and the timing of the equity contribution [1].
Compare gross proceeds to net proceeds after deductions
Models often display a gross sale price per unit. Bank supervisory guidance notes that for residential tract developments, the market value must reflect an analysis of appropriate deductions and discounts, including holding costs, marketing costs, and entrepreneurial profit [1]. Similarly, for condominiums, appropriate deductions and discounts typically include holding costs, marketing costs, and entrepreneurial profit during the sales absorption period [1]. Your model may need similar adjustments. Identify each deduction your model applies between gross sale price and net cash to the project. Common items include sales commissions, closing costs, holding costs during the absorption period, and any marketing expenses. If your model shows only gross proceeds, note that as an assumption that likely overstates available cash. The OCC guidance specifically warns that for condominium construction appraisals, banks may not use the aggregate retail sales prices of individual units as the market value to calculate loan-to-value ratios [1]. Your model should not either.
Check whether presales are assumed or verified
If your model assumes a certain number of units are already committed at a set price, verify whether those are bona fide commitments. Bank supervisory guidance notes that presales may not be a reliable indicator of actual future sales because purchase commitments may not result in sales if values decline [1]. Banks typically analyze whether presales represent bona fide commitments and whether deposits have been collected and are meaningful [1]. A suggested way to prepare is to list each presale, the deposit amount, and whether the deposit is refundable. If your model treats presales as guaranteed proceeds, flag that as an assumption that lender underwriting may discount.
Prepare a one-page evidence checklist
Create a single workpaper with the following columns: assumption, source of assumption, evidence you have, evidence you still need. For example, under absorption rate, note whether you have a market study or are estimating. Under release price, note whether you have a term sheet or are assuming a standard formula. Under equity timing, note whether you have a capital account statement or are projecting future contributions. This checklist becomes the document you attach to your preliminary package as a supporting file. It shows you have thought through each variable and are not treating the model's output as guaranteed.
Frequently asked questions
Does the OCC guidance apply to nonbank lenders? The OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook provides bank supervisory guidance for national banks and federal savings associations [1]. It does not directly bind nonbank lenders or borrowers. However, many nonbank lenders follow similar underwriting practices, and the guidance describes what a prudent lender typically reviews. Use it as a reference for what questions your model should answer, not as a rule every lender must follow.
Can I use the model's sale proceeds as my loan repayment source? The model's proceeds are an estimate based on your assumptions. Bank supervisory guidance indicates that for multiple-unit developments, banks typically require full repayment before the sale of all units, often through accelerated release pricing [1]. Your model should show whether proceeds after release payments and deductions are sufficient to repay the loan within the term. The model alone does not guarantee lender approval.
What if my model shows a loss on early units? A development that generates little developer profit on the lots, meaning the sales price is not sufficiently greater than the cost, will have difficulty paying off lots on an accelerated basis [1]. If early units show a loss or thin margin, that signals a potential underwriting issue. A suggested next step is to ask the actual lender whether they have minimum profit thresholds or release price formulas that would affect your cash flow.
The website supplies the call to action.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a multifamily acquisition or value-add model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).