Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Preparing questions about an existing lender's extension requirements

A practical evidence checklist to help sponsors prepare for extension or renewal negotiations with their existing lender, distinguishing source facts from assumptions and explaining how each piece of information affects the financing discussion.

Source: CodexTopic: Portfolio and repayment planning1262 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

A practical evidence checklist to help sponsors prepare for extension or renewal negotiations with their existing lender, distinguishing source facts from assumptions and explaining how each piece of information affects the financing discussion.

When a commercial real estate loan is approaching maturity and the sponsor needs an extension, the conversation with the existing lender is different from a new loan request. The lender already knows the property and the sponsor, but the underwriting standards that applied at origination may no longer reflect current market conditions. The OCC's guidance on refinance risk, which applies to banks supervised by the OCC, describes how lenders should evaluate a borrower's ability to refinance under prevailing conditions . This guide provides a concrete worksheet to help you prepare the information that will matter most in that discussion.

Understanding refinance risk from the lender's perspective

Refinance risk is the risk that a borrower will not be able to replace existing debt at a future date under reasonable terms and prevailing market conditions . For the existing lender, this risk increases when interest rates rise or when large volumes of loans mature in underperforming markets . The lender's concern is whether you can meet current underwriting standards, including prevailing interest rates, for a similar loan. Your preparation should focus on demonstrating that your property and financial condition can satisfy those standards today.

The extension evidence checklist

This worksheet lists the documents and workpapers you should gather before requesting an extension. For each item, note the source of the information and whether it reflects actual performance or projections. The goal is to compare your current position against the lender's likely underwriting criteria, not to assume what those criteria are.

1. Current rent roll (snapshot date)

Record the date of the rent roll and list each unit or tenant with lease start and end dates, base rent, any rent concessions or abatements, and security deposits. Distinguish between occupied and vacant space. This is a snapshot; it does not show historical trends. Compare the current rent roll to the rent roll at origination to identify changes in occupancy, tenant mix, or rent levels.

2. Trailing twelve months of operating statements (T-12)

The T-12 covers twelve consecutive historical months. It shows actual income and expenses, not projections. Record gross potential rent, vacancy and collection losses, effective gross income, operating expenses, net operating income (NOI), and any capital expenditures. The T-12 reveals trends that a single rent roll cannot, such as seasonal occupancy changes or rising expense lines. Compare the trailing twelve months to the underwriting pro forma from origination to see whether performance has met, exceeded, or fallen short of expectations.

3. Current operating statement (year to date)

This is the most recent partial-year statement. Record the same line items as the T-12 but note that the period is shorter. Compare the year-to-date figures to the same period in the prior year to identify recent changes. Do not annualize partial-year data without noting the assumption.

4. Debt service schedule

List all current debt secured by the property, including the existing loan, any mezzanine debt, and any other liens. For each, record the outstanding principal, interest rate, payment amount, maturity date, and any prepayment penalties or lockout periods. Also note any personal guarantees or recourse provisions. This schedule helps you calculate debt service coverage and shows the lender the total leverage on the property.

5. Capital expenditure history and plan

Record capital expenditures made during the loan term, including the date, amount, and purpose. Separately list any planned or needed capital improvements. The lender may want to see that deferred maintenance has not accumulated and that the property is being maintained or improved.

6. Sponsor financial statement and schedule of real estate owned

Prepare a current financial statement for the borrowing entity and for any guarantors. Include a schedule of all real estate owned, with each property's name, location, loan balance, and current status. The lender will assess your overall financial capacity and whether you have the liquidity to support the property during an extension period.

How to compare your current position to underwriting standards

Once you have gathered the evidence, compare each metric to the underwriting standards that the lender used at origination. The OCC notes that banks may require debt service coverage or loan-to-value requirements that provide a cushion if a borrower's financial condition declines or market conditions deteriorate . Ask the actual lender what current underwriting standards they apply to similar loans. Do not assume that the standards have not changed. Record the following comparisons:

  • Current debt service coverage ratio vs. origination requirement
  • Current loan-to-value ratio vs. origination requirement (use a current appraisal or broker price opinion for value)
  • Current occupancy vs. origination pro forma occupancy
  • Current NOI vs. origination projected NOI

If any metric has declined, identify the reason and whether it is temporary or permanent. For example, a temporary vacancy due to a tenant move-out may be different from a structural decline in market rents.

Preparing for the extension discussion

With the evidence checklist completed, you can prepare specific questions for the lender. The OCC's guidance suggests that effective analysis of refinance risk includes determining whether a borrower can meet current underwriting standards for similar loans . Your questions should focus on those standards, not on general market conditions. Suggested questions:

  • What are your current debt service coverage and loan-to-value requirements for an extension on this property type?
  • Do you require a new appraisal or environmental report for an extension?
  • What covenants or conditions would you include in an extension agreement?
  • Are there any prepayment or lockout provisions that would apply during the extension period?

These questions are a suggested way to prepare information, not a mandatory lender process. The lender may have its own specific requirements.

What to do if the extension is not granted

If the lender declines the extension or offers terms that do not work for your business plan, you may need to seek a refinancing from another lender. The process begins with a loan request that includes the business plan, sources and uses, the budget or operating history, the pro forma, and the sponsor's financial information [1]. Lenders are selected with the sponsor by property type, market, loan size, and structure before anyone is contacted [1].

FAQs

How do I know if my lender will grant an extension?

You cannot know without asking. The lender's decision depends on current underwriting standards, your property's performance, and market conditions. The evidence checklist above helps you prepare the information the lender will need to evaluate your request. Ask the actual lender what criteria they apply.

What is the difference between a rent roll and a T-12?

A rent roll is a snapshot of current tenant information at a single point in time. A T-12 is twelve months of historical operating statements showing actual income and expenses. The T-12 reveals trends that a single rent roll cannot, such as seasonal changes or rising costs. Both are important for the lender's analysis.

Does the OCC's guidance apply to my loan?

The OCC's guidance applies to banks it supervises, including national banks and federal savings associations . It is supervisory guidance, not a rule that binds every borrower or nonbank lender. However, many lenders follow similar practices. Use the guidance to understand what a bank lender may consider, but confirm with your actual lender what standards they apply.

Next step

If you would like help preparing your extension request or exploring refinancing options, send us the property, the business plan, the amount you need, and the timing. We will tell you how we would approach it.

Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. Wraith commercial real estate debt