Preparing evidence of completed capital work for a commercial refinance
A practical guide for sponsors to compile a capital-work evidence package that supports a refinance discussion, with a concrete document checklist and explanations of how the information affects lender underwriting.
A practical guide for sponsors to compile a capital-work evidence package that supports a refinance discussion, with a concrete document checklist and explanations of how the information affects lender underwriting.
When you have finished renovating a commercial property and are ready to refinance the construction or bridge loan, the lender will want to see proof that the work was completed as planned and that the property now supports the income projected in the business plan. This guide walks you through preparing that evidence, explaining how each piece of information affects the financing discussion and distinguishing what comes from supervisory guidance from what is a suggested way to organize your file.
The capital budget and the draw history
Start with the original capital budget that was part of the business plan. Record every line item: the scope of work, the budgeted cost, the actual cost, and the date each item was completed. Next to each, note the draw request that funded it and the amount of that draw. A suggested way to prepare this is a simple spreadsheet with columns for scope, budget, actual, variance, draw date, and draw amount. The OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook describes monitoring as including monthly reports of work completed, costs-to-date, costs-to-complete, construction deadlines, and loan funds remaining [1]. While that guidance is written for bank examiners, the same information helps a refinance lender confirm that the project stayed on budget and that loan funds were used for the intended work. If there are variances, note the reason and any approvals from the original lender or construction consultant.
The third-party inspection reports
If an independent construction consultant or engineer performed periodic inspections during construction, collect those reports. The OCC handbook notes that banks often retain an independent construction consulting firm if they do not have the necessary in-house expertise to perform a physical inspection [1]. Even if your original lender did not require such reports, having them now can strengthen your refinance package. A suggested way to organize is a chronological file of each inspection, with the date, the inspector's name and firm, the percentage of completion at that point, and any noted deficiencies and their resolution. If independent reports do not exist, identify that gap and collect the completion evidence and warranties actually issued by the contractor; ask the lender which further evidence it needs.
The certificate of occupancy and final permits
A permanent or bridge refinance lender will want to see that the property is legally occupiable for its intended use. Collect the final certificate of occupancy from the local building department, along with any temporary certificates that were issued during construction. Also gather the final signed-off permits for all major trades: electrical, plumbing, mechanical, and structural. If the renovation involved a change of use or an addition, include the approved site plan and any zoning letters. The OCC handbook discusses evaluating potential environmental liability risk and environmental factors that could affect the ability to recover loan funds in the event of a foreclosure [1]. While that is bank supervisory guidance, it points to why a lender may ask for evidence that the property complies with current building and environmental codes. If you have a Phase I environmental assessment prepared before or after the renovation, include it in the package.
The rent roll and lease abstracts after completion
The current rent roll is a snapshot of the property today. It shows each unit, the tenant, the lease start and end dates, the rent, any concessions, and the security deposit. A T-12 is twelve historical months of income and expense. Explain the timing difference: the rent roll shows the state of leasing now, while the T-12 shows what actually happened over the past year, including months when the property was still under renovation or lease-up. A refinance lender will compare the two to see whether the post-renovation income is meeting the projections. Distinguish gross rent from collected income: gross rent is the contractual amount, while collected income is what you actually received after vacancies, concessions, and bad debt. Net operating income (NOI) is collected income minus operating expenses. Capital expenditures (capex) are separate from operating expenses and are not deducted from NOI. Debt service is the principal and interest due on the loan. Equity cash flow is NOI minus debt service. A suggested way to present this is a table that shows the pre-renovation and post-renovation figures side by side, with the T-12 as the historical baseline and the current rent roll as the forward-looking snapshot.
The lease-up report and tenant improvement costs
If the business plan included leasing vacant space after renovation, prepare a lease-up report. This should list each new lease signed after the renovation, the date it was signed, the rent, the term, any concessions, and the tenant improvement (TI) costs paid by the landlord. Compare the actual lease-up pace and rent levels to the projections in the original business plan. If there is a gap, note the reason and any adjustments you made. The OCC handbook discusses evaluating whether the capitalization or discount rate is supportable and appears reasonable in terms of the class, property type, and market conditions [1]. While that is from an appraisal review worksheet for examiners, it highlights that a lender will want to see that the actual leasing results support the value conclusion. If the property is not yet fully leased, provide a leasing timeline and a projection for the remaining space.
The exit plan and the refinance assumptions
A bridge loan is typically expected to be repaid from a sale or a refinancing, often into a commercial permanent loan [2]. For a refinance, the lender will look at the exit: the business plan and leasing assumptions, the projected stabilized income, and whether that income and the resulting value will support the sale or refinancing the plan assumes [2]. A suggested way to prepare this is a one-page summary that shows the current loan balance, the projected stabilized NOI, the debt service on the proposed new loan, the debt yield (NOI divided by loan amount), and the debt service coverage ratio (NOI divided by debt service). Do not equate a cap rate with a debt constant: a cap rate is a valuation metric, while a debt constant is a loan repayment metric. If the proposed financing involves an interest rate cap, identify any premium as a separate cash requirement under the actual financing structure. Do not automatically add a one-time premium to recurring annual principal-and-interest debt service. The OCC handbook also discusses loan workouts and restructures for when a property is not performing as expected [1]. While that is not your goal, it is worth knowing that a lender may have a framework for evaluating a property that has not yet stabilized.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a rent roll and a T-12, and why does a lender want both? A rent roll is a current snapshot of the property's occupancy and rent. A T-12 is a historical report of actual income and expenses over the past twelve months. A lender compares them to see whether the post-renovation income is meeting the projections and whether the historical performance supports the current rent roll.
Does a lender require an independent inspection report if I already have a contractor's completion certificate? Not always, but an independent inspection report from a third party can strengthen your refinance package. The OCC handbook notes that banks often retain an independent construction consulting firm for physical inspections [1]. Even if your original lender did not require one, having one now can help confirm that the work was completed to industry standards.
What if the actual lease-up pace or rent levels are lower than the original projections? Be transparent. Provide a lease-up report that shows the actual results, explain the reasons for any gaps, and present a revised projection. A lender will evaluate whether the property can still support the proposed loan. The OCC handbook discusses evaluating whether the capitalization or discount rate is supportable and appears reasonable in terms of the class, property type, and market conditions [1]. This suggests that a lender will want to see that the actual results still support the value conclusion.
If you are preparing a refinance request and want to discuss how to present this evidence, send us the property, the business plan, and the capital you need. We will tell you how we would approach it. Submission is a preliminary request, not an engagement or lender submission.
Model this deal and request financing
Run a refinance model with your own numbers in the financing workbench. Results are calculated on the server with the assumptions shown. If you choose to send the request, you get a preliminary lender-package PDF and can attach your rent roll, T-12 or OM.
Opens the financing workbench operated by Wraith Real Estate. Nothing goes to any lender without Wraith's review and your agreement.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).