Preparing a closing issues list with dependencies and accountable owners
A practical worksheet for commercial real estate sponsors to identify, assign, and track each closing condition, its prerequisite tasks, and the person responsible—before the lender's term sheet arrives.
A practical worksheet for commercial real estate sponsors to identify, assign, and track each closing condition, its prerequisite tasks, and the person responsible—before the lender's term sheet arrives.
A closing issues list is a working document that tracks every condition that must be met before loan funds are released, the tasks required to satisfy each condition, and the person accountable for completing each task. Preparing one early—when you are assembling the loan request—gives you control over timing and helps you avoid surprises during the underwriting period.
What a closing issues list contains
A closing issues list records each closing condition as a line item. For each item, note the condition itself, the specific task or deliverable needed, any prerequisite tasks that must be done first, the owner accountable for completing the task, and the target date. The list lives in a shared spreadsheet or project management tool and is updated weekly.
Typical closing conditions include: satisfactory appraisal, environmental report, third-party reports (property condition assessment, zoning letter, survey), evidence of insurance, organizational documents for the borrowing entity, financial statements for the sponsor and guarantors, and legal opinions. The list also covers items the sponsor must produce, such as updated rent rolls, operating statements, and the sources-and-uses schedule.
How to build the list from the loan request
Start with the materials the lender will ask for. Convert each of these categories into a line item on the closing issues list.
For each line item, identify the dependency. For example, the appraisal cannot be ordered until the lender has engaged an appraiser from its approved list. [1] The OCC handbook notes that banks should use written engagement letters when ordering appraisals and should include those letters in the credit file. The appraisal review also must be performed to determine whether the methods, assumptions, and value conclusions are reasonable. So the task "order appraisal" depends on the lender providing the engagement letter and appraiser contact. The sponsor's task is to provide access to the property and any prior appraisals.
Assigning accountable owners
Accountable owners are the people or teams responsible for completing a task. They are not necessarily the people who will do the work, but they are the ones who answer for it. Common owners on a closing issues list include:
- Sponsor – for providing financial statements, organizational documents, property information, and access for inspections.
- Lender – for ordering the appraisal, environmental report, and other third-party reports; for issuing the commitment letter and loan documents.
- Sponsor's counsel – for reviewing loan documents, preparing legal opinions, and coordinating with lender's counsel.
- Third-party vendors – for completing the appraisal, environmental assessment, property condition report, and survey.
- Title company – for providing the preliminary title report and clearing exceptions.
Assign only one accountable owner per task. If a task requires multiple people, break it into subtasks.
Distinguishing dependencies from assumptions
A dependency is a task that must be completed before another task can begin. For example, the lender cannot issue the commitment letter until the credit committee has approved the loan. That is a dependency. An assumption is a belief about a future event that has not been confirmed. For example, assuming the appraisal will come in at the purchase price is an assumption, not a dependency. On the closing issues list, mark assumptions separately and track them as risks.
[1] The OCC handbook notes that cost overruns can erode a borrower's equity and reduce the bank's collateral margin. This is a risk to track, not a dependency on the closing issues list. The closing issues list should include a risk register alongside the task list, noting assumptions that could affect the timeline or the loan amount.
Reconciling the rent roll and operating statements
A current rent roll is a snapshot of occupancy and rent at a single point in time. A trailing twelve months (T-12) operating statement shows twelve historical months of income and expenses. These two documents serve different purposes and may not match. The rent roll shows scheduled rent; The T-12 reports historical income and expenses on its stated accounting basis. Differences can arise from vacancies, concessions, bad debt, or timing of rent collections. When comparing the two, note the reporting basis (cash or accrual) and reconcile the periods. [1] The OCC handbook discusses debt yield as the ratio of NOI to debt, and notes that debt yield is independent of interest rate, amortization period, and capitalization rate. Accurate NOI is important for underwriting.
Worksheet: closing issues list template
Create a spreadsheet with these columns:
- Condition – the closing condition (e.g., appraisal, environmental report, insurance certificate).
- Task – the specific deliverable or action needed (e.g., order appraisal, deliver rent roll, provide financial statements).
- Prerequisite tasks – what must be done before this task can start (e.g., lender must engage appraiser before appraisal can be ordered).
- Accountable owner – the person or team responsible.
- Target date – the date by which the task must be completed.
- Status – not started, in progress, complete, blocked.
- Notes – any relevant details, assumptions, or risks.
Fill in the first draft from the loan request materials. Update it at least once a week during the financing process. Share it with the lender and your advisors so everyone is working from the same timeline.
Using the list during underwriting
Once the term sheet is signed and the lender begins underwriting, the closing issues list becomes a communication tool. When the lender asks for additional information, add it as a new line item. When a third-party report is delayed, update the status and adjust target dates for dependent tasks. [1] The OCC handbook notes that banks should establish processes governing the removal of an appraiser from the approved list and should support reasons for removal that do not diminish appraiser independence. If the lender needs to replace an appraiser, that becomes a new task on the list.
Ask the actual lender about its specific requirements. Lenders differ on more than the interest rate. The closing issues list should capture each lender-specific condition as it arises.
FAQs
How detailed should the closing issues list be?
Include every condition that could delay closing, even if it seems minor. It is better to have too many line items than to miss one that becomes a bottleneck. Each line item should have a single accountable owner and a clear deliverable.
Who maintains the closing issues list?
The sponsor or the sponsor's project manager typically maintains the list, but it should be shared with the lender and all advisors. The list is a coordination tool, not a lender requirement. The lender may have its own checklist; the sponsor's list should complement it.
What if a task depends on the lender, but the lender does not assign an owner?
Note the dependency and flag it to the lender. Ask the lender to confirm who will handle the task and by when. If the lender does not provide an owner, escalate to the lender's relationship manager or credit officer. The list helps surface these gaps early.
Run the numbers on your deal
Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).