How to track appraisal questions without rewriting the appraiser's conclusions
A practical guide for sponsors to organize appraisal-related questions and evidence, distinguishing the sponsor's role from the appraiser's, with a concrete checklist to prepare for lender discussions.
A practical guide for sponsors to organize appraisal-related questions and evidence, distinguishing the sponsor's role from the appraiser's, with a concrete checklist to prepare for lender discussions.
When a commercial real estate sponsor receives an appraisal, the natural instinct is to check whether the value conclusion matches expectations. That is the lender's job. The sponsor's job is to understand what the appraisal says about the property's condition, market position and risk, and to track questions that arise without overstepping into the appraiser's conclusions. This guide explains how to prepare an appraisal evidence checklist that supports the financing discussion without rewriting or challenging the appraiser's work.
What the appraisal tells the lender
The appraisal is the lender's primary tool for determining collateral value. The OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook explains that appraisals must meet minimum standards, including reflecting appropriate deductions and discounts for properties such as residential tract developments [1]. For raw land or lot development, the market value should reflect the property's actual physical condition, use and zoning designation as of the effective date [1]. This means the appraisal contains specific factual assertions about the property that the lender will rely on. The sponsor should know what those assertions are.
What the sponsor should not do
The sponsor should not attempt to rewrite the appraiser's conclusions. The lender's appraisal review process is designed to determine whether the methods, assumptions and value conclusions are reasonable [1]. The sponsor's role is to provide accurate information about the property and business plan, not to substitute their own value opinion. The OCC handbook also notes that banks should establish processes for selecting and approving appraisers and for monitoring appraiser performance [1]. The sponsor should not interfere with those processes.
Prepare an appraisal evidence checklist
A concrete document the sponsor can prepare is an Appraisal Evidence Checklist. This is a simple workpaper that records the key factual assertions in the appraisal that the sponsor can verify or supplement. The checklist should include the following items:
- Effective date of the appraisal: Confirm this matches the property condition on that date.
- Property description: Compare the appraisal's description of the property's physical condition, use and zoning with the sponsor's own records.
- Comparable sales: List the comparable sales used in the appraisal. Note any that the sponsor believes are not truly comparable or that are missing.
- Income and expense assumptions: Record the appraiser's assumptions about rent, vacancy, expenses and capitalization rates.
- Deductions and discounts: Identify any deductions or discounts applied, such as for lot development or raw land.
- Value conclusions: Note the appraiser's concluded market value, but do not challenge it. Instead, record the factual basis for that conclusion.
The checklist should be a simple table or list, not a narrative. The sponsor can use it to track questions to ask the lender or the appraiser, without rewriting the appraisal.
Distinguish source facts from assumptions
The appraisal contains two types of information: source facts that the appraiser observed or received, and assumptions that the appraiser made about the property or market. The sponsor should distinguish between these. For example, the appraiser may assume a certain lease-up period or expense ratio. The sponsor should record those assumptions and compare them with the sponsor's own business plan. If the assumptions differ, the sponsor should note that and be prepared to discuss the difference with the lender.
How the checklist affects the financing discussion
The lender will review the appraisal to determine whether the value supports the requested loan amount. The sponsor's checklist helps the sponsor understand what the lender is looking at and whether there are any facts the lender should know that the appraiser may have missed. For example, if the appraiser used a comparable sale that closed after a major market change, the sponsor can flag that. The checklist also helps the sponsor prepare for lender questions about the appraisal's assumptions.
When to share the checklist
The sponsor should share the checklist with the lender only if the lender asks for it. The checklist is a working document for the sponsor, not a formal submission. If the lender raises a question about the appraisal, the sponsor can refer to the checklist to provide factual information. The sponsor should not offer the checklist as a replacement for the appraisal or as a critique of the appraiser's work.
Suggested way to prepare the checklist
A suggested way to prepare the checklist is to create a spreadsheet with columns for each appraisal section, the factual assertion, the source of that assertion (appraiser observation, sponsor-provided data, market report), and the sponsor's verification status (confirmed, differs, unknown). The sponsor can then use this to track questions to ask the actual lender or appraiser.
Distinguishing the sponsor's role from the lender's
The lender's appraisal review process determines whether the appraisal complies with regulations and the bank's policies [1]. The sponsor's role is to provide accurate information and to understand the appraisal's implications for the business plan. The sponsor should not attempt to perform the lender's review. Instead, the sponsor should focus on the factual evidence that the appraisal contains and how it affects the financing discussion.
Frequently asked questions
1. Can I ask the appraiser to change the value conclusion? No. The appraiser must remain independent. The OCC handbook includes a checklist question asking whether the appraiser is isolated from influence, pressure or coercion [1]. The sponsor should not attempt to influence the appraiser's conclusion. Instead, the sponsor can provide additional factual information to the lender, who may then request the appraiser to reconsider.
2. What if the appraisal uses assumptions that differ from my business plan? Record those assumptions in your checklist. Then discuss the differences with the lender. The lender may ask the appraiser to explain the assumptions or may accept the sponsor's business plan assumptions if they are supported by market evidence.
3. Should I share my checklist with the appraiser? No. The checklist is for the sponsor's internal use and for discussion with the lender. The appraiser should receive factual information only through the lender, not directly from the sponsor, to maintain independence.
Run the numbers on your deal
Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.
Talk through your financing
Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.
Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).