Can I Afford This Property?Commercial real estate financing, worked out

Documenting open insurance claims in a financing diligence file

How to prepare an evidence checklist that shows the lender how an open insurance claim affects property income, repair timelines, and collateral value.

Source: CodexTopic: Environmental and physical diligence1223 wordsUpdated 2026-11-19

How to prepare an evidence checklist that shows the lender how an open insurance claim affects property income, repair timelines, and collateral value.

When a property has an open insurance claim—whether from fire, flood, wind, or another insured loss—the lender needs to understand how that claim changes the property's current income, the planned repairs, and the collateral's value. This guide explains what evidence to gather, how to present it, and how the claim affects the financing discussion. It is not a generic overview of CRE financing; it is a concrete task for the sponsor preparing a loan request.

Identify the claim type and status

Start by recording the claim number, the date of loss, the type of peril (e.g., fire, wind, water damage), and the current status (open, under adjustment, partially paid, or disputed). The lender will want to see the insurer's acknowledgment of the claim and any correspondence about the scope of covered damage and the estimated repair cost. If the claim is still being adjusted, note the expected timeline for resolution. The OCC handbook notes that banks typically maintain copies of insurance policies and proof of premium payment showing the bank's interest is adequately protected against hazard and loss of rents [1]. An open claim does not automatically mean the property is uninsured, but the lender will want to confirm that the claim does not reduce coverage below the required amount.

Gather the insurance policy and endorsements

Provide the current property insurance policy declarations page, the loss payable endorsement naming the lender, and any endorsements that address the peril involved. If the claim involves business interruption or loss of rents coverage, include that policy or endorsement as well. The OCC handbook lists among documentation requirements copies of insurance policies and proof of premium payment that show the bank’s interest is adequately protected against hazard, liability, and, when appropriate, loss of rents and flood [1]. This is not a rule that every borrower must follow, but it is a standard expectation for bank lenders. Confirm with your actual lender what they require.

Prepare a repair timeline and cost estimate

If the claim covers physical damage, prepare a schedule showing the estimated repair cost, the amount already paid by the insurer, the amount expected from the insurer, and the amount the sponsor will fund from equity or other sources. Include a timeline for completion of repairs, with key milestones such as permit issuance, contractor mobilization, and substantial completion. The OCC handbook requires that for construction loans the documentation include a detailed cost analysis for hard and soft costs, as well as executed construction contracts and a completion bond [1]. For a repair project tied to an insurance claim, the same principle applies: the lender will want to see that the repairs are scoped, budgeted, and scheduled. If the repairs are not yet started, explain why—for example, waiting for the insurer's final adjustment or a contractor's availability.

Show the impact on operating income

If the property is income-producing and the damage has reduced rent collections, provide a current rent roll and a trailing twelve months (T-12) of operating statements. The T-12 shows historical income and expenses, while the rent roll is a snapshot of current leases and occupancy. Compare the two to show how the claim has affected gross rent, collected income, net operating income (NOI), and any loss of rents insurance proceeds received. The OCC handbook lists rent rolls and reports of past-due leases, including delinquent expense reimbursements, as typical documentation [1]. Distinguish between gross rent (total rent billed), collected income (rent actually received), NOI (income after operating expenses but before debt service), and equity cash flow (NOI minus debt service and capital expenditures). The lender will use this to underwrite the property's ability to service debt during the repair period.

Document the source of repair funds

Identify how the repairs will be paid: from insurance proceeds already received, from a reserve held by the insurer, from the sponsor's equity, or from a loan. If the sponsor is using equity, provide evidence of available funds (bank statements, line of credit, or a letter from the sponsor's accountant). If the claim proceeds are held by the insurer in a reserve, show the reserve balance and the conditions for release. The OCC handbook includes checklist questions asking whether records show the nature and purpose of disbursements for taxes and insurance and whether escrow accounts are reviewed at least annually [1]. While this guidance is directed at banks, a sponsor can prepare a similar reconciliation for the lender.

Reconcile the claim with the property's debt service

If the property has existing debt, show how the open claim affects the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR). Calculate the DSCR using the current NOI (after accounting for any rent loss) divided by the annual debt service. If the claim has reduced NOI below the lender's minimum DSCR, explain how the sponsor will cover any shortfall—for example, by using insurance proceeds, a reserve, or an equity infusion. The OCC handbook requires that banks assess the ability of the borrower to repay the loan in a timely manner [1]. An open claim does not automatically disqualify the property, but the lender will want to see a plan for maintaining debt service during the repair period.

Prepare a claim evidence checklist

Create a single workpaper that lists each item of evidence you have gathered, with the date it was prepared or received, the source, and any notes about gaps. Suggested categories: claim details (claim number, date of loss, peril, status), insurance policy (declarations page, loss payable endorsement, loss of rents endorsement), repair plan (scope, cost estimate, timeline, contractor contracts), income impact (rent roll, T-12, NOI comparison), funding sources (insurance proceeds received, reserve balance, sponsor equity), and debt service reconciliation (current DSCR, shortfall plan). This checklist is not a mandatory lender form; it is a suggested way to organize information so that the lender can quickly find what they need.

Frequently asked questions

What if the insurance claim is still being adjusted and the repair cost is not final? Record the estimated repair cost from the adjuster's preliminary report or the contractor's estimate, and note that it is subject to change. The lender will likely require a reserve or a contingency in the underwriting. Update the checklist as new information becomes available.

Does an open insurance claim automatically prevent a loan from closing? Not necessarily. The lender will evaluate whether the claim reduces the property's value or income below acceptable thresholds. If the sponsor can show that repairs will be completed promptly and that debt service will be maintained, the loan may still proceed, possibly with conditions such as an escrow for repair funds.

Should I include the insurance adjuster's report in the diligence file? Yes, if it is available. The adjuster's report provides an independent estimate of the damage and the covered amount. If the adjuster's report is not yet final, include the insurer's preliminary estimate or the sponsor's own estimate, and note the source.


We are not a lender and do not make loans or commitments. If you have a property with an open insurance claim and need to prepare a loan request, send us the property, the business plan, the amount you need, and the timing. We will tell you how we would approach it.

Run the numbers on your deal

Try your own NOI, value and lender tests to see which one limits the loan: DSCR, LTV or debt yield.

Open the loan sizing calculator

Talk through your financing

Working on a real property? Send us the deal and a financing advisor will review it and get back to you. It costs nothing to ask and does not commit you to anything.

Contact us

Requests are reviewed by Wraith Real Estate, a commercial real estate debt advisor (not a lender).

Sources

  1. OCC Commercial Real Estate Lending handbook
  2. Wraith commercial real estate debt